Pages

Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 2, 2011

On Alvin Plantinga's Discourse on "Truth and Worldviews"

"Alvin Plantinga is one of the most important and influential philosophers of the 20th and early 21st centuries.  His publications range over a wide variety of fields, but his most enduring contributions have been in metaphysics, epistemology, and, especially the philosophy of religion."  says the back of the little insert we got as a prize for walking into chapel.  Sounds like just my kind of guy!  Sounds like he knows everything!  Perhaps I was expecting too much.


To be honest, I was quite disappointed by Plantinga's chapel message this morning.  I was expecting that he would give us some new insights into philosophy and religion, but I got nothing new.  In fact, the entire time of his speech can be summed up as follows (substitute for "bad", "incompatible with Christianity" [his words]):


1.  Naturalism is bad.
2.  Anti-realism, though different, is also bad.
3.  Anti-realism leads to relativism, which is bad because it doesn't make sense.


That's it.  That's all he said.  He used impressive vocabulary and defined his terms well, but his method of discourse was surely lacking.


Side note: What are these things?  Naturalism says that the physical universe is all that is (i.e., there is no God). Anti-realism says that mankind is the author/architect of the known universe (anything that is, is because of us).  Relativism, according to him, says that there is no absolute truth ("Truth is collectively or individually constructed.").


He then throws out some statistics that say that most people don't believe in absolute truth, and then makes this statement:


"But obviously this is crazy."


Then later:


"How does [relativism] fit with Christian belief?  Very badly."


Just a statement, nothing more.  No explanation, no Biblical support, and despite being a world-renowned philosopher, no philosophical support.  He just claims that relativism "doesn't make sense" and declares it "incompatible with Christianity."


But why?  Did he even think about it?  I would think that he has, but he certainly gave no indication of it today.  If relativism is "obviously" crazy, then why do the majority ascribe to it?  Does that mean that 66% of adults and 72% of those aged 18-25 are crazy, or mentally ill?


I would consider myself part-naturalist, part-anti-realist, part-relativist, and yet still a God-believer, and it all makes sense to me!  True, pure relativism might not make a whole lot of sense, but you've got to do better than just claiming that it doesn't make sense.  The question is why doesn't it make sense?  Give us some proofs, or arguments based on anecdotal evidence at least!  Consider this:


With respect to science and humanities, I am a naturalist.  I believe that God created the universe, but I do not think that you have to believe that God created the universe in order to study it, learn from it, and better yourself through it.  There are plenty of atheist and Christian scientists all working to make the world a better place.


With respect to human endeavors, I am anti-realist.  God didn't put us on the moon...we put ourselves on the moon!  God didn't develop the polio vaccine...we did!  Does God take a back seat to our endeavors and leave us to our own devices?  Certainly not!  I don't deny that God is here, and that he is actively doing stuff, but we humans nevertheless accomplish things, sometimes good and many times evil.  We may not have created the universe, but God did leave it to us to cultivate it, use it, and architect it as we see fit.


With respect to truth, I am both a relativist and, well, whatever the opposite of a relativist is.  There is both absolute truth and there is relative truth.  For the relativist, we needn't look further than the laws of science to find absolute truth: What goes up must come down.  Like forces repel.  For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction.  These are truth.  For Plantinga et.al., we needn't look further than the Bible to find relative truth!  Consider one of my favorite passages, Romans 14:


"I know and am convinced in the Lord Jesus that there is nothing unclean in itself; still, it is unclean to the one who considers it unclean." (14:14)


What is Paul saying here?  He is saying that there are those who ascribe to the old Jewish laws and consider certain foods unclean, and there are those who deny the old laws and declare all foods clean.  For the one, it is sin to eat of unclean food, but for the other, it is only sin to be a stumbling block to the one who won't eat unclean food.  (Some) sin is relative!  Paul is convicted that no food is unclean, but he won't cause another to stumble by eating that food in front of them.  But is it actually sin or just the perception of sin?  Paul says:


"The faith you have, keep to yourself before God. Blessed is the one who does not judge himself by what he approves.  But the man who doubts is condemned if he eats, because he does not do so from faith, and whatever is not from faith is sin." (14:22-23)


So yes!  The very same act that is sin for one person is not sin for another person.  In this case, the sinfulness of the action is relative to the person doing the action.  (Though, you could argue that the sin lies not in the eating of unclean food, but rather by doing something against your convictions or by doing something not from faith.  In this case, the sin is therefore not relative because it is internally judged according to one's convictions instead of externally judged according to one's actions.  However, all the examples that Plantinga gave during his message were of external actions, such as poverty, war, lying, and "other ills", and his message seemed to be very externally-focused.)


What is the point of my diatribe?  I suppose the main point I would like to make is that it is wrong to just make a statement and proclaim it as truth.  Plantinga, a world-renowned philosopher, ought to do better than just saying that relativism is incompatible with Christianity and leave it at that.  What if he's wrong?  What is his reasoning?  Does his statement stand up to criticism?  Is he able to rebut a rebuttal?  We don't know, because he didn't address those things.  I feel like every single Monday-Wednesday-Friday-Sunday is like this.  Are we Christians afraid of criticism?  If not, then where's the criticism that should be there?