Continued from
Part 1.
This post is already getting really long, so I decided to split it up into two sections. Also note that these are all my initial reactions to McDowell's arguments. They are mostly based on my past experience and knowledge gained, but I do some research as well to make sure that my claims have some backing to them. So far I'm not proofreading any of my posts, so I apologize if they are somewhat cumbersome. Anyways, back to
Evidence That Demands a Verdict:
McDowell argues that the Bible is the most circulated book in history, ending this section with, "The critic is right: 'This doesn't prove the Bible is the Word of God!' But it does factually show the Bible is unique." Again, I argue that uniqueness does not imply specialness. It only shows that the Christian religion is the most widespread and/or fanatical religion, not that it is true.
Now the argument is that the Bible is the most translated book in history. Now, while that seems like a remarkable feat of accomplishment, doesn't this actually work to its detriment? For it is plain to any original languages scholar that the English Bible that we have today is not the same as the Greek New Testament of the first few centuries. Every time the Bible is translated, errors are made. Mostly small ones, but sometimes big enough errors are made (by mistake or purposefully for political reasons) that greatly influence doctrine and significantly alter the course of religion. (Need I cite again the "hell" issue, which was not on the minds of Jesus or the early church leaders, but due primarily to mistranslations permeates the contemporary Christian culture?)
McDowell claims next that the Bible is unique in that the manuscripts we have today show a very accurate portrayal of the original text, unlike any other writing we have. I will mostly grant this, that save for
some copying errors (which have been shown to exist), scribes were pretty careful not to mess up the copies. Still, it is not perfect, and I might expect an all-powerful God to perfectly preserve his word throughout the centuries. Still, I'll grant that the errors in the modern Bible due to scribal errors are generally insignificant. He also lays claim to the fact that the Bible has survived through much persecution over the millennia. True, but, "[t]his does not prove the Bible is the Word of God. But it does prove it stands alone among books. Anyone seeking truth aught to consider a book that has the above unique qualifications." So, what, no other unique religious book has been
burned,
banned, and outlawed? Certainly, many religions, religious writings, and religious people have been persecuted, leaving only the fittest religions behind. (Oh, the Christians are going to hate me for that analogy!) It's not like all but one religion has coupled under pressure.
The next big section, though difficult to summarize, seems to be saying that the Bible has undergone much criticism and come out standing "as solid as a rock." McDowell quotes a bunch of people saying the same thing, and then cites a couple instances where people have criticized the authorship of the Bible and said, "they have been shown to be wrong." I heartily disagree with this sentiment, for in all the study and research I have done, I have come to believe that the Bible is not so "solid as a rock" as McDowell would like to believe. I'll of course grant that some criticisms of the Bible have shown to be false (though I don't have extensive enough knowledge to comment on the ones McDowell cites), but just because a few people are wrong doesn't mean that
everyone who thinks like them is wrong. I can't say much more than this, though, for I need more education in this field of study. McDowell's argument, though valid, is weak and does not actually prove anything.
McDowell quotes a few people saying that because the Bible makes specific prophecies and that these have come true, it must be true. Of course, he fails to cite
any of these so-called fulfilled prophecies. If he had, I could go on a diatribe about statistical probability theory, but he fails to mention any of these prophecies that have taken place! However, in my experience, I have not found any kind of a fulfilled prophecy. Most recent is the utterly embarrassing May 21 "Judgement Day" prophecy uttered by Harold Camping. I'm willing to bet that for every "fulfilled" prophecy, we could chalk it up to coincidence and find hundreds, if not thousands, of prophecies that have not come true. But McDowell doesn't give one example. Do I expect too much?
He next claims the Bible to be impressive in its ancient historical account, which no other culture or religion can claim. This would be a valid point if the historical account were completely true, but I have heard that people have done studies and shown that, while the Bible does contain historical accuracies, it also contains historical falsehoods as well. But, I shouldn't fully endorse this point of view without saying that "more research is needed."
The next argument basically says, "The Biblical stories often paint their characters in a negative fashion, and if it were made up, they wouldn't have done this." I do like this argument, and I'll give McDowell a point for this one. I think that this is a very big assumption to make, for you cannot claim to know the motivation of writers dozens of centuries ago. What's to say that they
really believed that what they were writing was true? What's to say that they cared that their actions to look as "saintly" as possible? What's to say that it was always a first person account of the stories (as often it was not)? I don't buy this argument, but I can't quite fully refute it either. The motivations of ancient writers are lost in time. We cannot know why they did or did not write things down. It may provide some bit of evidence that what they were writing actually did happen, but there are so many unknown possibilities that I wouldn't put too much weight on it.
After stating to what great extent the Bible has influenced culture around it (sure, he gets another point here), McDowell states, "The conclusion is obvious. The above does not prove the Bible is the Word of God, but to me it proves that it is unique." Well yes, the Bible is unique. If all McDowell wanted to do was come to this conclusion, I'd have to agree with him. But his logic is flawed. He seems to be implicitly making the argument that
because the Bible is unique, it alone should be the source of truth. Like I said before, uniqueness does not imply specialness! Every religious book is unique, but that doesn't make any of them true!
So far I have been thoroughly unimpressed by McDowell's arguments, but perhaps they get better.