Pages

Sunday, October 30, 2011

Bad Sermons and Good Sermons

First of all, administrative: I think I might be pausing my McDowell series while I focus on the more recent Strobel series (I already have the introduction and first chapter done). For one, the Strobel book is WAY shorter, and much easier to refute. It's also more fun. But, I will come back to the McDowell book when that is finished. I just have too many Christian books to read.

And now, for the real content.

Christian, if you haven't realized yet, there are such things as good sermons and bad sermons. If you think all sermons are created equal, I'm sorry to break it to you, but they are most decidedly not. And I'm not talking about whether you like it or not--I'm talking vast differences in quality. Today, for instance, I endured a most painful sermon in a small evangelical church that shall not be named. In this small CMA church, the head pastor took a week off and let a guest pastor take the reins. I was only there to impress my family's friends, but I figured I would give the guy a chance anyways. Before the service began, I punched the verse that was in the bulletin into my Greek New Testament iPod app to get some background so I could better understand the wonderful sermon that was to follow. Oops. (The verse didn't even end up having anything to do with it, so, whatever.)

Oh. My. Science. I was completely unprepared for the horrid deluge of evil, vile shit that would soon spew from this man's mouth. (And, to be clear, I could probably count the number of times I have actually used cuss words on two hands. This should tell you something of the magnitude about how I truly feel about this sermon.) It was absolutely awful. It was so awful that I almost think I would have preferred listening to a hellfire sermon than the garbage he spouted. The basic premise was ok: "Guard your heart so that bad things don't get in and mess you up." Yeah, fine, but the way he delivered it was so god-awful that it made me almost physically sick. I was angry nearly from the start, when he compared the OWS protesters to the evil things that creep into your heart and "occupy" it. I was absolutely FURIOUS when he said that listening to "bad" music or watching "bad" shows turned you into a bad person. I...I don't even want to talk about it. In fact, I know I shouldn't, or I'll be here all day complaining, and it would not be pleasant. Suffice it to say that the brand of Christianity he espoused was not at all biblical, not at all true, and not at all Christian! Everyone else seemed to like it, though, which makes me really scared. I think of those poor children who will grow up in that church and be exposed to sinister, evil lies like that throughout their lives. They don't know any better. They won't know any better. I desperately wish I could save them from that kind of hell. But what can I do?

Then, on the other hand, you have quality sermons! Most of the sermons that come out of Mars Hill Bible Church are pretty good. They are biblically-based, decent words of wisdom, at least as far as Christian wisdom goes. But on the way back from the sickening church service this morning, my wife and I listened to a podcast of a sermon that was given by N.T. Wright on the sacraments a few weeks ago. Talk about night and day! Not only was his sermon fascinating from an educational and theological standpoint, but it was very well thought out, very biblical, and exposed very good theology and a rock solid faith. I hope the guest pastor's sermon never gets saved anywhere in digital form, but if you want to listen to N.T. Wright, I highly recommend it! Here is N.T. Wright on the Sacraments. If you want real quality teaching, take a listen to that.

This whole episode got me thinking more about the Evangelical community and what it means to be a Christian. I think a distinction ought to be made here, and I think it's a distinction that has been a long time in the making. It's offensive, but I've got to say it. Evangelicals, you are no longer Christians. Yes, I know you think you are, but you really aren't. You don't practice what you preach, nor do you even preach the Gospel of Jesus Christ. You have twisted and maligned the words of your Scriptures to such a degree that he would be utterly appalled by what he sees in Christianity today. You are the Evangelical community, but you're not Christian. You have sacrificed the love and grace of Jesus Christ for damning teaching and right-wing conservative agendas to get bigger numbers and to separate yourselves from others and divide yourselves into warring "us vs them" groups. You are divisive, corrosive, selfish, materialistic, and unworthy of the label of the God-man you claim to serve.

Catholics, you really aren't any better. You have sacrificed the humility and earthliness of Jesus Christ for the riches and powers of this world. Do you really think Jesus would be impressed by the fanciful, meaningless rituals and the grand cathedrals you have built? Do you really think he would approve of your idols? No, you too have lost the true meaning of Christianity a long time ago. You also do not deserve the label of the God-man you claim to serve.

True Christianity means something else entirely. Being a Christian means you are a follower of Christ. Evangelicals, I'm mainly calling you out here. You want comfort. You want the easy life. You want to go to church every week and be told that you're such a good person for being "saved," in the in-crowd. You're not going to leave your father and mother and all your possessions to go feed the poor, clothe the naked, and visit the prisoners. You're satisfied with throwing a bunch of money at printing Bibles rather than giving people what they really need. You aren't ready to accept one or a group of people who are different from you in any way or who intrude on your comfortable lifestyle. You don't have what it takes to be a follower of Christ. The moment you do, let me know, and maybe we'll have something to talk about. Hell, I don't believe in God or the deity of Jesus, and I'm more of a Christian than most of you. Try giving your money to starving children instead of "outreach" programs. Try loving your neighbor as yourself, even if your neighbor is black, teen-pregnant, or even gay. At the very least, start trying to spot bad teaching when it hits you square in the face. Not everything that comes from a pulpit is good or wholesome. Or Christian.

Friday, October 21, 2011

Q&A With Bishop Ed Little

The other day, David, my wife and I attended a local meeting of parishioners from Gethsemane Episcopal Church in Marion, IN (for that is where they will both be attending) to meet, greet, and Q&A with the Bishop of the Diocese of Northern Indiana, Rt. Rev. Edward S. Little II. (Fun fact: His father personally knew E.B. White, and his father's name was...Stuart Little.)

Anyways, I expected Bishop Little to be cool, but I didn't expect him to bethat cool! We all asked him some really hard questions, ranging from his life's background and religious experience, to the doctrine and structure of the Episcopal church, to modern issues facing the church including human sexuality and eschatology. I was rather impressed by his reasonableness, friendliness, and biblically accurate doctrinal positions and opinions. In fact, there is really only one doctrinal issue concerning God's salvific plan that I even found room to disagree on, but I do think that his position is very reasonable and mostly (if not completely) biblical. In a couple hours, I have gained a huge amount of respect for this man, for Father Jim from Gethsemane, and for the Episcopal church as a whole. If I were still a Christian, I would love to go there.

The only thing he talked about all night that really gave me pause was his discussion of his conversion and how he knows the truth of God. Essentially, he graduated from Ayn Rand to Christianity (a move, certainly, in the right direction) and from a modern kind of fundamentalist Christianity to a more reasonable, basic Christianity that he expresses now (though I am somewhat extrapolating this latter part). My problem is his basic justification for believing. As far as I could tell from what he explicitly said, it seems like the only reason he believes is because he "feels" God's presence and simply has faith. This is the same answer I keep getting from everywhere, and it is the reason that I simply cannot believe. (Among all the other reasons, but they are somewhat less important in light of this basic epistemological issue.) Faith, as it is trivially easy to prove, is not a valid way of knowing, and I have not met anyone who could prove otherwise. If I were ever to meet with Bishop Little again, I would pose that issue to him to see what he thinks.

But all this to say, Episcopals are cool! I like pretty much everything about them.

Sunday, October 9, 2011

New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 3 - Is the New Testament Historically Reliable? - Part 1

McDowell gives three criteria for establishing the reliability of the NT: the bibliographic test, the internal evidence test, and the external evidence test.


The bibliographic test argues that our extant copies of the NT is reliable because of the method and timeline with which they were passed down:

  • Our earliest extant copies of significant portions are "very close" in time to the date of their writing (250-300 years).
  • The number of extant manuscripts of the NT are great in number (counts vary but average around 5600).
  • Errors due to scribal errors and deliberate misinterpretations are minor, and no disputed passage influences central Christian doctrine. (Though, I would argue that you would have to define "central Christian doctrine" very narrowly for this to apply; say, the doctrine of the Apostle's Creed, which is a fair standard.)
  • There are various versions in different languages.
  • There are a plethora of quotes of the NT from early church fathers.
Much of his argument here is summarized in yet another quote (I am finding that over 50% of this book is quotes from other people.): "Since scholars accept as generally trustworthy the writings of the ancient classics even though the earliest MSS were written so long after the original writings and the number of extant MSS is in many instances so small, it is clear that the reliability of the text of the N.T. is likewise assured." Of course, this is true, all other things being equal. I would not be so bold as to say that all other considerations are equal, seeing as how early Christianity was fraught with rivalries and heresies and arguments. It cannot be disputed that the NT was very controversial, and it seems to me that this fact alone would give many people reason to be altered. Nevertheless, I will cede the point to McDowell (or, rather, the people he quotes).