Think about the changes that have taken place in your immediate family over the course of your life. Assuming you had a typical American childhood (or perhaps atypical?), you probably had a lot of rules and chores when you were young. You may have even had a system of rewards and punishments for good and bad behavior. Assuming you've graduated college by now or otherwise live apart from your parents, you probably don’t have systems like this anymore. You’re an adult now, and your parents realize that. You understand what responsibility is and how to make proper decisions. Granted, you still make mistakes, but you have a much more complete understanding of the world now than you did and you are now much more trustworthy. This pattern of “growing up” and leaving behind the rigid structure of rules and regulations is called maturity.
The world is a messy place, and to cope with it when we are young, we need the guidance of those who are more mature than us, and we need a rigid, black-and-white structure to define our thoughts and actions. It is right to go to bed on time, eat your vegetables, and say please and thank you. It is wrong to tell a lie, throw a tantrum, or disobey. Study hard and you will get an A, but disrespect your parents and you will get a spanking. All sensible (or maybe not so sensible) rules, and many of these rules apply to us later on in life.
When we are immature, we don’t know how things work, we don’t know what’s best, and we don’t know how to make proper decisions. As we mature, we learn how to think rationally. We open our minds to a myriad of possibilities and we ask questions. We seek out the answers to our questions, learn things, and repeat the process. As we grow, we become less dependent on a specific set of rules, because we are able to think for ourselves.
This is true of children growing up, and it is true of academic studies as well. Unfortunately, what the church often fails to grasp is that it is true of Christians, too! When we first start believing in our faith, we are spiritually young and immature. We need a rigid structure of rules that tell us right from wrong, acceptable from unacceptable. Sometimes this is called doctrine, sometimes it is called other things, but it nearly always comes from the mouth of someone in authority—someone more spiritually mature.
But as time passes, Christians mature (or they ought to). They already understand the fundamentals, but they yearn for more truth. They start to ask questions. Then they start asking difficult questions. But all too often, their questions are stifled, because they are told that “good” Christians don’t ask hard questions. “Good” Christians only need to have faith and believe whatever they are told. This is not only discouraging, but it is very detrimental to their spiritual growth, just as it would be to tell a child to always obey no matter what and never ask questions!
Pastors, teachers, and parents are afraid that if their children are right where they think they should be, then questions will only lead them away from that place. However, this fear is irrational! A person need not be doctrinally consistent with another person to have a good, healthy relationship with them, whether they be a church attendee, a student, a child, or a spouse. If we never question our faith, we will never mature in it, and we will be stuck at the same level of spiritual understanding for a very long time. It is only by breaking down this rigid structure of rules and doctrine that we start to understand things, learn things, and discover truth.
God works this way too. Consider the Israelites of the Old Testament. How often do pastors enjoy comparing them to naïve little children! As a brand new “chosen people”, they needed a host of rules and regulations in order to keep them in line, some of them sensible and some not so sensible, but all for their benefit. However, when Jesus came, he came to liberate God’s chosen people from this structure. He started changing the rules and made people think much more carefully about them. God no longer wanted a people who blindly followed a set of ridiculous laws, but he desperately desired a people who would challenge the status quo and seek the truth, even if it involved breaking some rules and changing some doctrine!
God desires this from us today. We should not be content with who we are spiritually, but we should always seek to better ourselves and to better our understanding of God. This process of growing more mature involves some painful things. It involves letting go of old beliefs and experimenting with new ones. Sometimes this change isn’t always for the better (that is, toward God), but if a person is honestly seeking truth, no one should stand in his way. God will use anything and everything to draw people closer to him.