Pages

Friday, January 28, 2011

Reaching Out

I recently read a blog post that explains very well where Christians go wrong in trying to "convert" people, and where unbelievers go wrong in trying to "deconvert" them.  The author of this post describes her conversion experience as a slow, step-by-step process:

It wasn’t arguments, persuasive or otherwise, that got me to either one of the extremes. It wasn’t proofs and reports. It wasn’t people railing against what I believed. It was hearing and listening, little bits at a time. It was done in my own time. It was opening doors, just a crack here and there, testing things out. It was seeking out confirmation other peoples’ experience, through books and websites. It was two steps forward and one step back.


You can’t whack people over the head and expect them to change immediately. You can’t try to argue them out of a corner they have painted themselves into. You can’t force the truth onto them. It takes awhile to change a mindset. I had to overcome internal resistance to the fact that I might be wrong. This is never easy. To admit I might be wrong takes courage, even if I am just admitting it to myself.


So don’t lambaste, don’t rail, don’t argue. Don’t try to force the door open because what will happen is that [they], with their integrity at stake, with their whole belief system and world view in jeopardy will lock that door with multiple locks, they will jam a chair up under the doorknob, they will alert the authorities that someone is trying to force their way in and they will close themselves off even more.


Instead, try some compassion. Remember that a lot of us were there at one time, too. Make suggestions. Offer different ways of looking at things. Be an example. Share your story. Instead of trying to force the door open, slip a little note under the door. Maybe they will read it, if not now, then later. [Theresa, 2007]


I think where we get into trouble is when we try to argue our position and never get past that point.  Yes, formal debate is wholesome and valuable, but most of the time we are not involved in formal debate.  Most of the time, we are interacting with others and building relationships with them.  If the majority of what we do is argue, how does that help our case?  Perhaps we should be less prone to judging and more prone to being neighborly with those whom we disagree with.  Experience has shown me that that is the best way to reach out to others.

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Happiness of Joy

I pulled the following verbatim from a friend's blog, as it is a very wise observation about our source of joy:

I read through a friend's blog post recently that contrasts the differences of happiness and joy. Travis writes: "A good life can't rely on places, jobs, or people for hope and confidence... that would be like relying on scratch lotto tickets for a stable financial future".

Happiness is circumstantial. Circumstances that are unpleasant are most often out of our control. Joy is more of a foundation. A foundation that gauges our reactions and satisfactions. A foundation based of our faith and beliefs. Joy is the hope of knowing an outcome to an unpleasant circumstance.

Joy based on the wrong beliefs is not joyful, even under happy circumstances. Read Ecclesiastes 2:1-17. Uncountable happy circumstances only resulted in an astounding grievous response.

Now read Nehemiah 8:10. Mainly the part about "do not be grieved, for the joy of the LORD is your strength". This is a command, do not! Do not grieve, why not? Because the LORD is the foundation of our joy, and the foundation is secure. This is written in Nehemiah in a time that the Israelites had been in captivity. Read that as an unpleasant circumstance. Even in times of distress one can have joy if their foundation is secure.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Commentary: Matthew 16:18

Matthew 16:18 is an interesting verse.  I've heard lots of interpretations of it and lots of interesting theology drawn from it.  (For example, Catholic tradition uses this verse to lay the doctrine that Peter is the first Pope, a position given to him by Christ himself during this dialogue.  Evangelicals, of course, like to say other things.)

The main argument by Evangelicals is that, since the text says "the gates of Hell shall not prevail against [the church]," that must mean that the church ought to be on the offensive against the powers of Hell, instead of just standing by and idly defending itself from accusation. The intended emotion that pastors like to stir up by using this verse is excitement and resolve—a call to action.

But I question if we can really get that kind of theology from this verse.  If God really wanted us to "go to war," as it were, I imagine it would be a major theme of the New Testament instead of relegated to the subtext behind a sole half of a verse.  Certainly, there are instances where God's people take up arms against their opponents, but isn't Jesus' life characterized by passive resistance and humble silence, for example, when being interrogated by the Sanhedrin?

I would like to propose an alternate interpretation of this verse based on a reading of the original text.  And in so doing, there are three important things to consider.

  1. First, the word translated Hell in the original Greek is actually hades.  In the Septuagint, the word sheol (grave) is translated into the Greek as hades, indicating that this is a place where all dead were sent, both righteous and unrighteous.  Sheol is first and foremost a place of separation from God.  The concepts of the immortality of the soul and reward and punishment in hades began later in rabbinic Judea.  The word hades occurs only ten times in the New Testament, described as a place within the earth, a prison with gates—the key to which is held by Jesus Christ, and a place which will, one day, give up its dead.  According to Acts 2:27,31, the dead, including Jesus Christ, are sent to hades; but, according to his promise, God raised Christ from the dead (that is, hades) so that his body would not "experience decay." [Information paraphrased from the New International Dictionary of New Testament Theology, Abridged Edition, by Verbrugge.]
  2. The Greek word that is translated as "prevail against" is katischuo.  This word can take several meanings, among them "to be strong to another's detriment," "to prevail against," "to be superior in strength," or "to overcome."  The Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd edition, by Danker and Bauer, defines katischusousin in the context of Matthew 16:18 as "to have the capability to defeat, win a victory over."  (Katischusousin is the form of the word katischuo that actually appears in the text.) In fact, the KJV renders this word as "prevail against," but most other translations render it as "will overcome."  It stands to reason, then, that it is not the intention of the author that hades is unable to withstand the onslaught of the church, but simply that it will not ultimately prove stronger or more powerful than it.  It is not clear from the text who exactly is supposed to be "on the offensive" against the other.
  3. Above all, if we were to translate it as a call to arms against Hell, who would we really be fighting?  Who created Hell?  Who is going to Hell?  Popular Christian doctrine tells us that Satan is the creator, sustainer, and "leader" of Hell, but this is not so!  No, God is the creator of everything, both good and evil, heaven and Hell.  Satan does not rule over Hell; indeed, Hell was created especially for him, for that is where he will be "tormented there day and night forever and ever" (see Rev. 20:7-10).  Jesus himself holds the keys to Hell.  An attack against Hell would be an attack against its Creator, that is, God, and the justice he chooses to bring against those who are sent there.
In conclusion, the words of Jesus in this verse do not necessarily imply that the church must go "on the offensive" against the forces of Hell.  Rather, the text simply says that death and despair will prove to be no match for the Church that Jesus is building, starting with Peter.  No matter who is on the offensive, God will ultimately rise victorious.

Special thanks to David C. for assisting with this commentary.

Monday, January 17, 2011

We Are Nomads

Perhaps you can recall a time when someone you loved began to seriously doubt what, before, was a simple black-and-white issue.  You may have even been concerned that this person was losing their faith, or that they were betraying the fundamental elements of your system of belief.  It is certainly tempting to think this way, but one very important lesson I've learned is that we must be careful to not mistake the journey for the destination.

Essentially, we are nomads, in the figurative sense.  We are on a journey, moving from place to place in our faith, occasionally camping at oases along the way.  But we don't make our home there for very long before we realize that it is only a stop along the journey--not the ultimate destination.

This moving from place to place is called growth, and it requires a certain amount of spiritual maturity.  Not everyone is cut out for a journey like this.  There are many people who cannot or refuse to give up what they have learned to call "home".  These people are settlers.  They are so comforted by what they know, that for them, it is truth.  Is this a bad thing?  No, not necessarily.  Hopefully, conservatives who like to build a residence right where they are not move know their system of beliefs very well and are very comfortable with them.  This is both a blessing and a curse.  Indeed, there have been many times I have envied people in this position.

However, we nomads wander around from place to place.  We cut ties with what we once believed and allow our minds to be open and free.  Again, this is a blessing and a curse.  On the one hand, it means we are not limited to a rigid structure of dogma that plagues modern churches today; on the other hand, however, it means we are more susceptible to be swayed by that which isn't truth.  But even this is not necessarily bad!  After all, our journeys are not yet complete.  Just because we've found truth in something doesn't mean we have finally found absolute truth in everything.  No, there is always a point at which we discover something new and have to leave the comfort of our temporary oasis.

We don't seek to move the settlers away from their homes unless they want to join us in our quest for truth.  I understand that leaving behind the things you cherish the most for an unexplored country can be difficult, but we nomads have been called to explore this deeper, richer understanding of God.  Need I remind you of Abraham?  That is us.  We will be tested and tried along the way, and we will discover pitfalls and vipers and brigands and all sorts of nastiness that you wouldn't find in your comfy home back in Egypt.  But God calls us anyways and promises to see us through to the Promised Land, and we choose to open our minds and simply go where he leads.

Consider Jesus rebuking the Pharisees, for whom all religion was a matter of black-and-white ethics.  Once, God said to keep the Sabbath holy, but Jesus now says that it is good to heal on the Sabbath.  He was trying to tell them that there is something that transcends the black-and-white "Thou shalt" and "Thou shalt not" way of thinking. That's what we nomads seek--the true love of Jesus Christ that encourages us to heal on the Sabbath, question our old way of thinking, and embark on a journey to the Promised Land.

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Indescribable

Indescribable, uncontainable
You placed the stars in the sky and You know them by name
You are amazing God
All powerful, untameable
Awestruck we fall to our knees as we humbly proclaim
You are amazing God

We used to like this song, but like all modern worship songs, we quickly grow tired of them and move on to Chris Tomlin’s newest hits.  Still, it’s a good song.

The idea, which seems to be a fairly universal idea among Christians, is that God is beyond description.  His might, his love, his compassion, and all his other attributes are so much more than we can comprehend.  There are no words that can fully describe his awesomeness.

So then why do we try to describe him?  Despite calling God “indescribable”, we use words to describe him all the time.  And then when we collect a group of these words together, what we end up with is a particular view of God.  This view of God is nothing more than a collection of words which, by our own admission, is hardly a sufficient description for the creator of the universe.  If God is bigger than any collection of words can describe, then he is also bigger than any internalized view of him we might have.

Thus is the source of much confusion, anger, and heated debates amongst God-believers.  We readily admit that no one can fully know or comprehend God, yet we often claim absolute knowledge about various aspects of God, and we too often try to push our view of God on other people, even other Christians.  What right do we have to do this?

To better comprehend this idea, consider that God is like a huge, multi-faceted diamond.  As spectators, we all exist in various positions around the diamond, looking at each of its thousands of facets from different points of view.  Everyone’s view of it is different, yet we are all still looking at the same thing.  As such, no one can make claim to describing the intricate structure of the entire diamond but can only attempt to describe the view from his particular position.  It is a rare and beautiful event indeed when one person shifts himself so that he is looking at the diamond slightly differently, giving him a slightly different perspective of its grand radiance.

So it is with God.  As long as we are all looking at the same thing, we can appreciate our respective differences of view and put them together in order to try to understand what the diamond is really like as a whole.  Granted, if someone is looking at a false diamond or something else entirely (say, an elephant), their view can’t be of much use to describing the real thing.  But just because two people have different conceptions of God doesn’t mean one is wrong.

In J.P. Phillips’ book Your God Is Too Small, he describes many different false views of God that are common among Christians.  For example, one view might peg God as a policeman, always making sure we follow the rules and punishing us when we trip up.  Another view might imagine God as a very old-fashioned man, stuck in his ways and not understanding the young person's world today.  Sure, these views might hint at various characteristics of God, but they are either wholly inadequate or altogether wrong!  God is so much bigger than anything we imagine!  We ought to not get so wrapped up in our meager notions of God that we miss opportunities for seeing the big picture.

By the way, these opportunities, by their very nature, can only come from the perspectives of others.  And if God is so powerful, can he not use the perspective of anyone, regardless of their personal convictions?  It might sound reasonable for a Christian to listen to the perspective of a Roman Catholic and see a bigger picture of God, but is it also not reasonable that one can listen to the perspective of an African witch-doctor, or, dare I say it, from the perspective of a practicing homosexual, and still get a glimpse of God's truth?

Does that mean that every person is "saved" or "following the one true God"?  No, not necessarily.  But if God has revealed himself to them, as we claim he does, then they may still have a firm grasp on an aspect of the one true God that has eluded you for a long time.  Who are you to deny the almighty God an opportunity to teach you about him through one of his beloved children?

Saturday, January 15, 2011

Conflict Transformation

Most people, especially us introverts, hate conflict.  You might paradoxically say that they are "at war" with conflict.  Extroverts less so, but all humans have an innate desire to avoid it.  It causes stress, it causes worry, and it fragments relationships.  And when handled improperly, it can and often does lead to disaster on all sides of the conflict.

There are a great number of books and workshops about conflict resolution.  Depending on whom you ask, different people might define conflict resolution differently.  But all of them would rate conflict as a negative experience and wholly undesirable.  And that right there is the problem we have with it.

We are so ingrained in thinking that conflict is a bad thing that we completely dismiss a crucial idea that could literally transform our lives.  This transforming idea is simple: conflict is not necessarily a bad thing, and, if used properly, it can even be a good thing!  We need to shift our view of conflict from something bad that needs to be resolved, to something good that can be used to transform.  Enter conflict transformation.

Conflict transformation sees conflict and disagreement as valuable tools and learning experiences instead of things to be avoided.  Instead of trying to quickly eradicate it when it arises, we instead see it as the "spice of life"!  In this view, conflict with another person does not mean that they hate us or that there is a barrier between us.  Instead, it is simply a reminder that we are two different people and that at the moment, there is something we don’t agree on.

In fact, we have disagreements with everyone all the time.  It’s just that most of the time, these disagreements are unknown or aren’t brought to the surface.  When they do get brought up, though, it takes careful reasoning and a tight rein on our emotions to keep us from getting carried away.  Conflict transformation helps us understand that most of these issues that get brought up are just petty differences anyways; when no course of action is required, we can all just agree to disagree and be on our merry way.  When the source of the disagreement is on a course of action, then both parties can either compromise or, if compromise isn’t possible, just pick one course of action and choose to be happy with it, understanding that the other person harbors no ill will toward us.

We often get way too uptight about far too many trivial issues.  If we just take a step back and look at these issues from a higher perspective, we realize that they don’t really matter, and it doesn’t really matter if the other person agrees with us.  In the rare case that an issue is important, then we ought to open our minds to a more formal debate, carefully analyzing both sides of the issue, and attempting to see the issue from the other person’s perspective before throwing around any harsh words or ultimatums.  But part of the maturity that comes from this is learning what kinds of issues are truly important and which are silly differences of opinion.  Strong emotion tends to cloud this faculty of reasoning.

A key feature of conflict transformation is that conflicts don’t necessarily have to be resolved.  Conflict transformation is partly a realization that disagreements can linger, and as long as all parties agree to disagree, then there is no real problem!  Differences of opinion are what make us unique individuals.


And when our emotions are hurt and we feel betrayed or damaged, it still is not necessary to come to an agreement.  Conflict is damaging when we try to discover the winner.  Conflict transformation does not seek a winner but instead seeks to transcend the conflict without looking for who is right or wrong.  Often, both people are right (or wrong, or both)!  But even if the conflict has a person who is “right” and another who is “wrong”, it still may not be necessary to seek it out, at least not right away.  The key in conflict transformation is treating others properly, not becoming morally superior by winning an argument.

Another way that conflict can transform us is by teaching us to choose our battles carefully.  With most issues, we don’t really need to get everyone thinking the same way we do.  Let them have their opinions!  We have ours, but it doesn’t mean that everyone needs to share them.  A lot of the time, conflict can be avoided simply by remaining silent.  We may know what’s right better than the other person, but that doesn’t mean we have to share our mind every single time something comes up.  Most enemies will go away if you simply ignore them.

Above all, view conflict as a gift from God.  Instead of thinking that the God of peace wants nothing more than for us to find the winner on every issue, we ought to instead see conflict as a tool for learning and growing toward others and toward God.  Conflict can be a wonderful way to learn about another person, and I can't think of anything more potent than conflict with God to draw you closer to him.

Friday, January 14, 2011

Structure and Maturity

Think about the changes that have taken place in your immediate family over the course of your life.  Assuming you had a typical American childhood (or perhaps atypical?), you probably had a lot of rules and chores when you were young.  You may have even had a system of rewards and punishments for good and bad behavior.  Assuming you've graduated college by now or otherwise live apart from your parents, you probably don’t have systems like this anymore.  You’re an adult now, and your parents realize that.  You understand what responsibility is and how to make proper decisions.  Granted, you still make mistakes, but you have a much more complete understanding of the world now than you did and you are now much more trustworthy.  This pattern of “growing up” and leaving behind the rigid structure of rules and regulations is called maturity.

The world is a messy place, and to cope with it when we are young, we need the guidance of those who are more mature than us, and we need a rigid, black-and-white structure to define our thoughts and actions.  It is right to go to bed on time, eat your vegetables, and say please and thank you.  It is wrong to tell a lie, throw a tantrum, or disobey.  Study hard and you will get an A, but disrespect your parents and you will get a spanking.  All sensible (or maybe not so sensible) rules, and many of these rules apply to us later on in life.

When we are immature, we don’t know how things work, we don’t know what’s best, and we don’t know how to make proper decisions.  As we mature, we learn how to think rationally.  We open our minds to a myriad of possibilities and we ask questions.  We seek out the answers to our questions, learn things, and repeat the process.  As we grow, we become less dependent on a specific set of rules, because we are able to think for ourselves.

This is true of children growing up, and it is true of academic studies as well.  Unfortunately, what the church often fails to grasp is that it is true of Christians, too!  When we first start believing in our faith, we are spiritually young and immature.  We need a rigid structure of rules that tell us right from wrong, acceptable from unacceptable.  Sometimes this is called doctrine, sometimes it is called other things, but it nearly always comes from the mouth of someone in authority—someone more spiritually mature.

But as time passes, Christians mature (or they ought to).  They already understand the fundamentals, but they yearn for more truth.  They start to ask questions.  Then they start asking difficult questions.  But all too often, their questions are stifled, because they are told that “good” Christians don’t ask hard questions.  “Good” Christians only need to have faith and believe whatever they are told.  This is not only discouraging, but it is very detrimental to their spiritual growth, just as it would be to tell a child to always obey no matter what and never ask questions!

Pastors, teachers, and parents are afraid that if their children are right where they think they should be, then questions will only lead them away from that place.  However, this fear is irrational!  A person need not be doctrinally consistent with another person to have a good, healthy relationship with them, whether they be a church attendee, a student, a child, or a spouse.  If we never question our faith, we will never mature in it, and we will be stuck at the same level of spiritual understanding for a very long time.  It is only by breaking down this rigid structure of rules and doctrine that we start to understand things, learn things, and discover truth.

God works this way too.  Consider the Israelites of the Old Testament.  How often do pastors enjoy comparing them to naïve little children!  As a brand new “chosen people”, they needed a host of rules and regulations in order to keep them in line, some of them sensible and some not so sensible, but all for their benefit.  However, when Jesus came, he came to liberate God’s chosen people from this structure.  He started changing the rules and made people think much more carefully about them.  God no longer wanted a people who blindly followed a set of ridiculous laws, but he desperately desired a people who would challenge the status quo and seek the truth, even if it involved breaking some rules and changing some doctrine!

God desires this from us today.  We should not be content with who we are spiritually, but we should always seek to better ourselves and to better our understanding of God.  This process of growing more mature involves some painful things.  It involves letting go of old beliefs and experimenting with new ones.  Sometimes this change isn’t always for the better (that is, toward God), but if a person is honestly seeking truth, no one should stand in his way.  God will use anything and everything to draw people closer to him.

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Grace Over Judgment

In a myriad of potentially explosive situations, there are often two types of treatments to the situation: give grace or give judgment.  All too often, the church (and, admittedly, us individuals) tend to pass judgment on others, on one another, and even on themselves.  Homosexual?  Outcast!  Masturbation?  Sinner!  Democrat?  Misguided!  Atheist?  Hell-bound!  Guy who almost ran me over?  Idiot!  Anyone who disagrees with me?  Stupid!

But why?  I believe that it is nothing short of feeding our own egos and inflating our self-perceived pretentiousness that we pass judgment on others, even if (perhaps especially if!) the judgment is real or deserved.  From a typical modern Christian perspective, will atheists go to hell?  Yes.  But does that give us a right to condemn them?  Absolutely not!

We have many disagreements with many people, but the fact that we disagree doesn’t give us license to treat others as inferior, no matter who is right.  Hebrews 10 quotes Deuteronomy 32 when the author says, “For we know the one who said, ‘Vengeance is mine, I will repay,’ and again, ‘The Lord will judge his people.’ ”  Judgment belongs to God, not to us.

And even then, the overwhelming theme of Jesus’ ministry on earth was not one of judgment but rather one of abundant grace!  Jesus doesn’t condemn the woman with many husbands, but he speaks to her with grace and kindness and offers her the life that can be found in him!  When the disciples were being idiotic morons, he didn’t split his church over the issue, but he accepted their failings and shortcomings and continued to teach them, even when his most loyal disciples turned away from him!  Even when he angrily overturned the tables of the money changers, he did so not because they were breaking the rules but because they were exploiting the people and making it difficult for them to worship God.  It was grace.

Even Jesus chose grace far more often and with greater fervor than he chose to judge people.  His ultimate sacrifice is the most convincing act of all!  It was during this time that he forgave the soldiers for torturing and killing him, while he continued to stand by and let them do it!  “Father, forgive them, for they do not know what they do.”

Yet all too often, we take the low road and pronounce judgment instead of grace on those who are wrong, as if doing so somehow finds favor with God.  If Jesus calls on us to imitate him, should we not stop passing judgment and start doling out grace on even our most disagreeable of acquaintances, friends, family, or lovers?  God certainly doesn’t need you or me in order to effect judgment on his enemies.  In my opinion, I think he’ll handle it just fine without our help.

Welcome!

Occasionally, I have thoughts.  I have long since discovered that my optimal medium for expressing my thoughts is through writing.  And after a recent visit to an awesome counselor with my friend, my head was swimming with thoughts.

So, I took the notes from that session and crafted my thoughts into maybe-coherent short essays and sent them to all my friends who were interested (read: my friend who went with me and my wife).  My friend then said, "You should make a blog out of these."  So here they are, for all the world to see.  Enjoy.  I'll post one a day for the next few days, and then keep posting them as I keep writing them.

(If any of my musings spark an interest of discussion, I am more than open to discussing them, either through comments, email, or in person.)