"God loves us.This is a pretty good summary of the first chapter of Rob Bell's new book Love Wins. He, like I and many others, is deeply troubled by the concept of hell. It raises lots of questions, and there are certainly a lot more questions here than answers.
God offers us everlasting life by grace, freely, through no merit on our part.
Unless you do not respond the right way.
Then God will torture you forever.
In hell."
Huh?
It would certainly be worth $12 [or current price on Amazon] if only it would get a churchgoing person to read the questions and be introduced to the issues.
Many people think they have a very neat and tidy view of salvation, but Bell attacks this tidiness with a great deal of mess in the form of logical inconsistencies, arguments from existential repugnance, and a whole host of questions.
- Why is it that everyone claims that there is only a small group who will be saved, but they invariably put themselves in that group?
- How can young children, if they do not yet understand, be sent to hell? Is there an "age of accountability"?
- If so, wouldn't it be more loving to kill children before they reach this age so that they will automatically go to heaven?
- What if a person dies just before being saved? If they were going to get saved, will they still go to hell?
- What about people who "get saved" but then proceed to live a wholly ungodly life? Are they still saved?
- What must you do to be saved? Must you pray a certain prayer, take a particular class, be baptized in the appropriate way, or do something else in order to "be saved"?
- If you have to do one of these things to be saved, then how is it a gift anymore? Isn't that the same thing as preaching salvation by works, which Christians claim separates theirs from all other religions?
- If all that matters in this life is doing whatever it is you need to do in order to go to the right place (heaven), then why care about this earth or this life at all?
Perhaps the thing that struck me the most in his opening chapter is something I've been wrestling with recently. For a long time, I thought that "God" was God. As long as you invoked the name spelled G-O-D, or perhaps J-E-S-U-S, then everyone knew who you were talking about. But I have come to understand that not everyone who uses those names refers to the same entity.
I have personally rejected God. But the question that Bell brings up is, Which God? Just because a person has rejected Christ doesn't mean they have rejected the true Christ.
He then finishes out his first chapter by pointing out some interesting things about the Bible. Beneath it all, Christians like to say that what truly matters is that you have a personal relationship with God. Except that...that is nowhere to be found in the Bible. Nowhere does it talk about being saved by having a "personal relationship" with God. Furthermore, it talks about many ways that various people have been "saved":
- John 3: Nicodemus is saved by being "born again."
- Luke 20: "Those who are considered worthy" will be saved.
- Matthew 6: Jesus tells his disciples that they can only be forgiven by "forgiving others."
- Matthew 7: Jesus says that only those who "do the will of my Father" will enter the kingdom.
- Matthew 10: Those who "stand firm" will be saved.
- Luke 19: Zacchaeus is saved by giving half his possessions to the poor and paying back his debts.
- Mark 2: The crippled man is saved by the faith of his friends.
- 1 Corinthians 7: Husbands can save their wives, and wives can save their husbands.
- 1 Timothy 2: Women will be saved through childbearing.
- Acts 22: Paul is saved because God pounced on him and asked him a question.
So, Bell asks, which is it? What truly saves you, and is it something you do or something someone else does?
Questions, questions, questions. My favorite part of life is asking questions, and questions abound in this chapter. Not many answers, but the questions alone are worth the book's weight in gold.
It should be noted that this book is a very easy read. I've not heard any of Rob Bell's sermons or read his other books, but he speaks with a fine eloquence directed at the common person. I've no doubt that the rest of the book will be filled with theology and philosophy, but it is not at all inaccessible to the average reader.
