The bibliographic test argues that our extant copies of the NT is reliable because of the method and timeline with which they were passed down:
- Our earliest extant copies of significant portions are "very close" in time to the date of their writing (250-300 years).
- The number of extant manuscripts of the NT are great in number (counts vary but average around 5600).
- Errors due to scribal errors and deliberate misinterpretations are minor, and no disputed passage influences central Christian doctrine. (Though, I would argue that you would have to define "central Christian doctrine" very narrowly for this to apply; say, the doctrine of the Apostle's Creed, which is a fair standard.)
- There are various versions in different languages.
- There are a plethora of quotes of the NT from early church fathers.
Much of his argument here is summarized in yet another quote (I am finding that over 50% of this book is quotes from other people.): "Since scholars accept as generally trustworthy the writings of the ancient classics even though the earliest MSS were written so long after the original writings and the number of extant MSS is in many instances so small, it is clear that the reliability of the text of the N.T. is likewise assured." Of course, this is true, all other things being equal. I would not be so bold as to say that all other considerations are equal, seeing as how early Christianity was fraught with rivalries and heresies and arguments. It cannot be disputed that the NT was very controversial, and it seems to me that this fact alone would give many people reason to be altered. Nevertheless, I will cede the point to McDowell (or, rather, the people he quotes).

0 comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Comments require moderation.