I probably won't comment as much on this chapter, because it appears to be basically the same as the first chapter from the previous book, with no new major sections. It still stands that the main point McDowell is making is, "The Bible is unique among religious books, so that makes it worthy of attention." But of course, every religious text is unique, and the Bible shares more in common with them than McDowell is willing to admit. It is simply a non sequitur to claim that uniqueness implies specialness.
He did change one sentence in his conclusion that I would like to draw attention to. Instead of saying, "The above does not prove the Bible is the Word of God, but to me it proves that it is unique," he says, "The evidence presented above does not prove that the Bible is the Word of God. But to me it clearly indicates that it is uniquely superior to any and all other books." While I could admit to his original statement, his revision is superbly elitist and plays directly into my rebuttal. No, unless you first assume that God exists and is like who you think he is like, then you cannot jump from "the Bible is unique" to "the Bible is superior to all other books." This is plain intellectual dishonesty.
So far, I am not impressed.
Home › mcdowell › New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 1 - The Uniqueness of the Bible

0 comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Comments require moderation.