As it turns out, McDowell's book The New Evidence That Demands a Verdict is simply an edited and compiled version of his previous two books. This thing is a beast. I'm thinking I should take a slow and steady approach to it, like one chapter a week. In a couple weeks I will be receiving Dawkin's new book, The Magic of Reality: How We Know What's Really True, and I will want to review this book too (as I eventually want to review Keller's The Reason for God and give it a thorough rereading). So much to do, so little time! Compound this with the fact that I am now addicted to Minecraft, and we have a real problem here...
At any rate, I started skimming the introduction to New Evidence, and while I am not giving it a thorough reading, there are a couple of differences I noticed.
McDowell spends a lengthy section discussion the problem with postmodern deconstructionism. While I do agree that contemporary thought is pervaded by a sense of postmodernism, I think that there is a healthy balance of modernism and postmodernism. Too much of one philosophy causes problems. So, without really reading his section, I'll just assume that I agree with him for the most part.
He also examines some logical issues surrounding Eastern mysticism, but since I am about as far from Eastern religions as I can be, I don't feel the need to visit this topic.
McDowell added something, I believe, to his section on Atheism. This is what he says (sorry, quotes): "Sartre found atheism 'cruel,' Camus 'dreadful,' and Nietzsche 'maddening.' Atheists who consistently try to live without God tend to commit suicide or go insane. Those who are inconsistent live on the ethical or aesthetic shadow of Christian truth while they deny the reality that made the shadow." This is absolutely, unequivocally false! Where do I even begin? First of all, to call on Sartre, Camus, and Nietzsche as the representative voices of all atheists is utterly disingenuous. They had massive philosophical and personal issues that do not apply to many, many people. Second, to claim that all atheists who are happy are only happy because of Christianity is completely dishonest to the discussion (if there is one). The point here is to question and critique Christianity, not assume it to be true! Comments like this make me wonder if McDowell is really taking an honest step back or if he is just trying to reassure people who are already Christians who are having doubts, for it does nothing to convince a nonbeliever.
He then discusses agnosticism, and makes several logical fallacies. McDowell seems to be indicating that agnosticism is an alternative to atheism, when in fact they are compatible. I should know, for I am both! A theist is someone who actively believes in a deity; an atheist is someone who actively disbelieves in a deity; an agnostic is someone who believes that absolute certainty about knowledge is unattainable. Most of us are agnostics, and this is something I've come to learn about the world from a very young age. It is not possible to know with absolute certainty that the sun will rise tomorrow, let alone that there is an invisible undetectable supernatural deity. I still believe that the sun will rise, and I have a mountain of evidence pointing to the fact that it will, but I can't claim to know it for sure. Likewise, I am an agnostic atheist. I disbelieve in a deity, but I don't claim to know this with 100% certainty. McDowell counters, "The fundamental flaw in Kant's hard agnostic position is his claim to have knowledge of what he declares to be unknowable. In other words, if it were true that reality cannot be known, no one, including Kant, would know it. Kant's hard agnosticism boils down to the claim: 'I know that reality is unknowable.' " But this isn't true! Now, I don't know what Kant would say, but I claim that, though reality is not ultimately certain, I still have a massive pile of evidence that points me in the direction of the truth. I may not know it 100%, but I do know it 99.9999999%, and that is enough statistical weight to allow me to live my life and claim to know something. There is a huge difference between "having no knowledge of reality" and "not having absolute certainty about reality." (In fact, somewhere in this introduction, McDowell even admits to being an agnostic theist! He says that he cannot prove for sure that God exists, but the evidence points him in that direction, so that is what he believes. As McDowell would say, case closed.)
Then begins the argument from "science." McDowell appeals to the classic argument against evolution by chance, the "obvious" need for an intelligent designer, and some ludicrous false statements about the nature of the universe. The science in this section is so badly done, I am disgusted to even look at it. To make matters even funnier, he even cites Carl Sagan (a staunch atheist and brilliant physicist) in an effort to bring some credibility to his claims. Scientists are either quoted out of context or are just flat-out wrong, for science has ultimately proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that this universe, this solar system, this planet, and this species can and do arise independently, without the need for an intelligent creator.
Home › mcdowell › New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Introduction

0 comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Comments require moderation.