Pages

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Video Games as Art

I just read a most excellent article by Brian Moriarty on his defense of Roger Ebert's statements that video games are not, and can never be, art.  It is a very good read, and I highly recommend it.


Brian, himself a longtime part of the video game industry, elaborated and defended his thesis with the epitome of tactfulness and fluency.  I won't go over everything he says (much of which is superb), but I must disagree on one major point, and, consequently, his conclusion.


Brian states that video games are best defined by Sid Meier as "an interesting series of choices."  Video games are all about the player making choices, which means that the player is in control, defining his own experience.  Books and movies, on the other hand, are authored purely by an external agent.  In explaining why video games are inferior to books and movies, Roger Ebert says, "Video games by their nature require player choices, which is the opposite of the strategy of serious film and literature, which requires authorial control."


Video games can surely contain art, as their interdependent constituents (the audio and video, for examle) can most certainly be classified as art.  But, Moriarty and Ebert say that the very nature of video games themselves (the control given to participants) excludes them from being able to attain status as "great art."  It is here that I disagree.


Consider, for instance, some games for which this is most definitely true, as demonstrated beautifully in Bioware's RPGs Dragon Age and Mass Effect.  In these examples, the whole point of the game is that the player makes choices that affect the rest of the game, including the plot and ending.  You, the player, have a choice to kill the person or not, or to defile the ashes or not, and so decide the fate of the rest of the game.  Of course, the main plotline is scripted, but enough variations were built in that you have effective control over many major plot points, ultimately being the author of your particular playthrough.


This, I would agree, is fun and enjoyable, but is not great art.  But the issue that Moriarty and Ebert must address is that this approach to gaming is relatively new!  Most video games that have been created don't have this kind of branching structure that allows you to control the underlying aspects of the game.  And some of these games would be considered novel, classic, and in my humble opinion, "great art."


Case in point: Braid.  Braid is novel; nothing like it has ever been done before.  Braid is creative.  Braid explores game dynamics that manipulate time and the relationship between time and space.  Braid has a story.  Braid is beautiful.  Braid is subtle.  Braid engages the mind.  Braid is, simultaneously, both simple and complex.  Braid is art, nay great art.


Braid is a video game, yes.  The player controls a character, moves it around the two-dimensional screen, and solves puzzles with it.  Yet, I would not make the claim that there is any choice involved by the player.  Most of the puzzles in the game have only one solution; only a few have multiple solutions, and the choice of which solution the player uses to solve the puzzle has absolutely no bearing on the story or the ending whatsoever.  The only other choices available to the player are in which order to solve some of the puzzles (they are all eventually required) and whether or not to pursue the optional challenge puzzles.  (In traditional art, I might compare this to which order to admire the characters in a painting, or whether or not you choose to explore a particular facet of a sculpture, the point being that there is no more choice in Braid than there is in a participant's interaction in a painting or sculpture.)


Braid is very linear and has a very defined story.  Like a movie, the game is designed in a very particular way so as to carry the participant through the story in a way that reveals the plot (and gameplay mechanics) in an appropriate fashion, culminating in a climax where the plot "trick" is revealed and it all suddenly makes sense.


Furthermore, Braid has incredible replay value (analogous to how you would want to watch a movie again despite already seeing the plot revealed), not due to rediscovering how to solve the puzzles, but due to reexperiencing the story, trying to figure out all the little details despite knowing the ending.  Art is attractive, and makes you want to experience it again and again.  Even though I know how to easily solve all the puzzles in Braid, I find myself playing it over and over again because every time I play, I understand more of the symbolism, more of the story, and more of the message of the game that was placed there by the artist(s).  Like in any piece of great art, the author of Braid is trying to tell you something that can only be told through participation in the experience of the artwork.


And Braid isn't the only game that does this.  Consider other great classics of the video game era, such as Portal, Final Fantasy VII, and even the Monkey Island series.  I argue that these games are great art.  They are (arguably) novel, they are beautiful, they are even funny, and they present a story constructed by one or more authors that the player is asked to participate in and appreciate.  That's exactly what traditional art does, only more passively.


Finally, consider that video games are in the fetal stage compared to media such as painting and sculpture, which have been around for millenia.  Give the video game medium some time, and we will begin to see some really great pieces arise out of it.  Meanwhile, enjoy the subtle complexities of Braid, the dark humor of Portal, and the stunning HDR landscapes in FFVII (?) and then go watch a Kubrick film.

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Comments require moderation.