I'm smart, I'll admit it. I'm more humble about it nowadays, but the truth is that I understand things, especially from a logical and scientific point of view. Unfortunately, this means I can't be a good Christian because I don't buy into the modern notion of God.
For example, one of our pastor couples went on a missions trip to Mali, Africa. That's great, it really is. They got back, and yesterday she (the female half of the couple) preached on a mashup of Genesis 22 and their trip to Africa, the whole point being about how "God provides," like how God provided for Abraham and how God provided for them during their trip.
Only problem is, I just don't buy it. Some key examples that were cited include how God provided enough money for them to go, how he provided for them by keeping them from getting sick, and how he provided her courage to eat icky things.
And most people accept these fine examples of God's provision. But I don't. The reason is, I can explain very rationally how these things happened. God didn't give them money to go to Africa; they asked for money publicly and people gave it to them! God didn't protect them from getting sick; they got their immunizations like they were supposed to and their immune systems were strong enough to fend off disease! God didn't give her courage to eat gross things; she was able to restrain her gag reflex long enough to consume the icky foods! All these things work just fine without God.
When we resign God to the farthest corners of our intellect, he will continue to shrink as we understand more. Perhaps this is why the church discourages intelligence and understanding. But God is so much bigger than that! Shouldn't the Almighty God encompass everything in creation, instead of only those things we don't yet understand? If we truly believed that, then we could learn all there was to learn in the universe without feeling that we are reducing the scope of God's sovereignty in the process.
And that's my problem with God. Either I'm missing something huge (unlikely that millenia of science has all been completely wrong), or perhaps we ought to rethink how we look at things and say "God did it"?
Home › All posts
Monday, March 21, 2011
Wednesday, March 16, 2011
Video Games as Art
I just read a most excellent article by Brian Moriarty on his defense of Roger Ebert's statements that video games are not, and can never be, art. It is a very good read, and I highly recommend it.
Brian, himself a longtime part of the video game industry, elaborated and defended his thesis with the epitome of tactfulness and fluency. I won't go over everything he says (much of which is superb), but I must disagree on one major point, and, consequently, his conclusion.
Brian states that video games are best defined by Sid Meier as "an interesting series of choices." Video games are all about the player making choices, which means that the player is in control, defining his own experience. Books and movies, on the other hand, are authored purely by an external agent. In explaining why video games are inferior to books and movies, Roger Ebert says, "Video games by their nature require player choices, which is the opposite of the strategy of serious film and literature, which requires authorial control."
Video games can surely contain art, as their interdependent constituents (the audio and video, for examle) can most certainly be classified as art. But, Moriarty and Ebert say that the very nature of video games themselves (the control given to participants) excludes them from being able to attain status as "great art." It is here that I disagree.
Consider, for instance, some games for which this is most definitely true, as demonstrated beautifully in Bioware's RPGs Dragon Age and Mass Effect. In these examples, the whole point of the game is that the player makes choices that affect the rest of the game, including the plot and ending. You, the player, have a choice to kill the person or not, or to defile the ashes or not, and so decide the fate of the rest of the game. Of course, the main plotline is scripted, but enough variations were built in that you have effective control over many major plot points, ultimately being the author of your particular playthrough.
This, I would agree, is fun and enjoyable, but is not great art. But the issue that Moriarty and Ebert must address is that this approach to gaming is relatively new! Most video games that have been created don't have this kind of branching structure that allows you to control the underlying aspects of the game. And some of these games would be considered novel, classic, and in my humble opinion, "great art."
Case in point: Braid. Braid is novel; nothing like it has ever been done before. Braid is creative. Braid explores game dynamics that manipulate time and the relationship between time and space. Braid has a story. Braid is beautiful. Braid is subtle. Braid engages the mind. Braid is, simultaneously, both simple and complex. Braid is art, nay great art.
Braid is a video game, yes. The player controls a character, moves it around the two-dimensional screen, and solves puzzles with it. Yet, I would not make the claim that there is any choice involved by the player. Most of the puzzles in the game have only one solution; only a few have multiple solutions, and the choice of which solution the player uses to solve the puzzle has absolutely no bearing on the story or the ending whatsoever. The only other choices available to the player are in which order to solve some of the puzzles (they are all eventually required) and whether or not to pursue the optional challenge puzzles. (In traditional art, I might compare this to which order to admire the characters in a painting, or whether or not you choose to explore a particular facet of a sculpture, the point being that there is no more choice in Braid than there is in a participant's interaction in a painting or sculpture.)
Braid is very linear and has a very defined story. Like a movie, the game is designed in a very particular way so as to carry the participant through the story in a way that reveals the plot (and gameplay mechanics) in an appropriate fashion, culminating in a climax where the plot "trick" is revealed and it all suddenly makes sense.
Furthermore, Braid has incredible replay value (analogous to how you would want to watch a movie again despite already seeing the plot revealed), not due to rediscovering how to solve the puzzles, but due to reexperiencing the story, trying to figure out all the little details despite knowing the ending. Art is attractive, and makes you want to experience it again and again. Even though I know how to easily solve all the puzzles in Braid, I find myself playing it over and over again because every time I play, I understand more of the symbolism, more of the story, and more of the message of the game that was placed there by the artist(s). Like in any piece of great art, the author of Braid is trying to tell you something that can only be told through participation in the experience of the artwork.
And Braid isn't the only game that does this. Consider other great classics of the video game era, such as Portal, Final Fantasy VII, and even the Monkey Island series. I argue that these games are great art. They are (arguably) novel, they are beautiful, they are even funny, and they present a story constructed by one or more authors that the player is asked to participate in and appreciate. That's exactly what traditional art does, only more passively.
Finally, consider that video games are in the fetal stage compared to media such as painting and sculpture, which have been around for millenia. Give the video game medium some time, and we will begin to see some really great pieces arise out of it. Meanwhile, enjoy the subtle complexities of Braid, the dark humor of Portal, and the stunning HDR landscapes in FFVII (?) and then go watch a Kubrick film.
Brian, himself a longtime part of the video game industry, elaborated and defended his thesis with the epitome of tactfulness and fluency. I won't go over everything he says (much of which is superb), but I must disagree on one major point, and, consequently, his conclusion.
Brian states that video games are best defined by Sid Meier as "an interesting series of choices." Video games are all about the player making choices, which means that the player is in control, defining his own experience. Books and movies, on the other hand, are authored purely by an external agent. In explaining why video games are inferior to books and movies, Roger Ebert says, "Video games by their nature require player choices, which is the opposite of the strategy of serious film and literature, which requires authorial control."
Video games can surely contain art, as their interdependent constituents (the audio and video, for examle) can most certainly be classified as art. But, Moriarty and Ebert say that the very nature of video games themselves (the control given to participants) excludes them from being able to attain status as "great art." It is here that I disagree.
Consider, for instance, some games for which this is most definitely true, as demonstrated beautifully in Bioware's RPGs Dragon Age and Mass Effect. In these examples, the whole point of the game is that the player makes choices that affect the rest of the game, including the plot and ending. You, the player, have a choice to kill the person or not, or to defile the ashes or not, and so decide the fate of the rest of the game. Of course, the main plotline is scripted, but enough variations were built in that you have effective control over many major plot points, ultimately being the author of your particular playthrough.
This, I would agree, is fun and enjoyable, but is not great art. But the issue that Moriarty and Ebert must address is that this approach to gaming is relatively new! Most video games that have been created don't have this kind of branching structure that allows you to control the underlying aspects of the game. And some of these games would be considered novel, classic, and in my humble opinion, "great art."
Case in point: Braid. Braid is novel; nothing like it has ever been done before. Braid is creative. Braid explores game dynamics that manipulate time and the relationship between time and space. Braid has a story. Braid is beautiful. Braid is subtle. Braid engages the mind. Braid is, simultaneously, both simple and complex. Braid is art, nay great art.
Braid is a video game, yes. The player controls a character, moves it around the two-dimensional screen, and solves puzzles with it. Yet, I would not make the claim that there is any choice involved by the player. Most of the puzzles in the game have only one solution; only a few have multiple solutions, and the choice of which solution the player uses to solve the puzzle has absolutely no bearing on the story or the ending whatsoever. The only other choices available to the player are in which order to solve some of the puzzles (they are all eventually required) and whether or not to pursue the optional challenge puzzles. (In traditional art, I might compare this to which order to admire the characters in a painting, or whether or not you choose to explore a particular facet of a sculpture, the point being that there is no more choice in Braid than there is in a participant's interaction in a painting or sculpture.)
Braid is very linear and has a very defined story. Like a movie, the game is designed in a very particular way so as to carry the participant through the story in a way that reveals the plot (and gameplay mechanics) in an appropriate fashion, culminating in a climax where the plot "trick" is revealed and it all suddenly makes sense.
Furthermore, Braid has incredible replay value (analogous to how you would want to watch a movie again despite already seeing the plot revealed), not due to rediscovering how to solve the puzzles, but due to reexperiencing the story, trying to figure out all the little details despite knowing the ending. Art is attractive, and makes you want to experience it again and again. Even though I know how to easily solve all the puzzles in Braid, I find myself playing it over and over again because every time I play, I understand more of the symbolism, more of the story, and more of the message of the game that was placed there by the artist(s). Like in any piece of great art, the author of Braid is trying to tell you something that can only be told through participation in the experience of the artwork.
And Braid isn't the only game that does this. Consider other great classics of the video game era, such as Portal, Final Fantasy VII, and even the Monkey Island series. I argue that these games are great art. They are (arguably) novel, they are beautiful, they are even funny, and they present a story constructed by one or more authors that the player is asked to participate in and appreciate. That's exactly what traditional art does, only more passively.
Finally, consider that video games are in the fetal stage compared to media such as painting and sculpture, which have been around for millenia. Give the video game medium some time, and we will begin to see some really great pieces arise out of it. Meanwhile, enjoy the subtle complexities of Braid, the dark humor of Portal, and the stunning HDR landscapes in FFVII (?) and then go watch a Kubrick film.
Tuesday, March 15, 2011
Love Wins
Rob Bell's new book, Love Wins, is coming out soon, and I've already preordered a copy (two, actually). Ironically, an opinion article in last week's Echo denounced Rob Bell and his teachings as heretical. This prompted a response from me, which may or may not be published.
But at any rate, I plan on reading through Bell's book as soon as I get it and reviewing it chapter by chapter here on this blog. With any luck, I'll be able to discuss it with one of the philosophy profs over lunch sometime.
But at any rate, I plan on reading through Bell's book as soon as I get it and reviewing it chapter by chapter here on this blog. With any luck, I'll be able to discuss it with one of the philosophy profs over lunch sometime.
Thursday, March 10, 2011
Fear of the Unknown
I had an interesting experience a couple weeks ago. I took my wife up to South Bend to visit some friends and see Lord of the Dance at the Morris Performing Arts Center. (Awesome show, by the way!)
We went with our friends to church in the morning. First service, which we went to, is a very traditional service, whereas there are two second services--one traditional and one contemporary, but the same pastor preaches the same message for all the services (he's projected for the contemporary service). After first service, we participated in our friend's "Sunday School". The pre-Sunday-school conversation eventually drifted towards the technical (not my fault!) as people were discussing email and the like. What someone said caught my attention.
The gist of what she said is that she doesn't want to use Gmail anymore. The reason? "It's too creepy." I'll admit, I don't think I've ever heard that one before. She explained that Gmail now displayed ads that were related to the content of her email messages. (Actually, it has been that way for a long time.) The result? Creepiness. How does she know, for instance, that someone isn't sitting there reading her email messages and picking out advertisements that were relevant?
Well, of course, this is obviously silly. Except that, it is not obvious to some (perhaps many) people. If it were obviously silly, then there wouldn't be a problem! There are a number of issues that might come into play here, such as numerical estimation (How many emails are sent through Google per minute, and how long does it take to read the average email, and how long would it take to pick out relevant ads, so how many people would Google have to employ to perform this task?), cost-benefit analysis (If a person were being paid to read emails and deliver ads, how much would they be paid per hour versus how much profit would Google make out of people clicking on relevant advertising versus non-relevant advertising? Would it be worth it?), and sheer logical impossibility (Emails are delivered in a matter of seconds, much much faster than any human could possibly read the email and select ads to display next to it.) So, when you think about it, it is obviously silly to think that someone is actually sitting there reading your emails all day.
But for some reason it is still "creepy", perhaps because this person did not ever stop to think about it. And that is fine. Some people aren't very capable of estimating numbers, performing cost-benefit analysis, or thinking logically through a problem. I don't judge people for not being mathematically-minded. However, I am concerned about the outcome. When she noticed that Gmail was doing something strange and didn't understand the process, it engendered fear. This, I think, is the root of the problem, and is the point of my spiel.
Why does the unknown cause fear? Especially something so silly and small as our email privacy? This I do not fully understand. Personally, when I see something that doesn't work the way I think it should, I get curious. I ask myself, "Why does it behave like that?" and "How does it work?" and "What must I learn in order to better understand it?" This is because I realize that understanding is within the realm of possibility. For others, though, instead of raising their curious nature, they get afraid of what they don't understand.
So then what about God? It is no errant thing to say that many people are afraid of God, or the concept of God. Even many Christians are afraid of God for many reasons. If I don't "do things" just right, will I lose my salvation? What if I'm not saved? Have I angered God? Will I fall out of favor with him? What if I sin one too many times? Will I go to hell?
Furthermore, these things are preached from the pulpits. For one, they quote the proverb "The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom," so therefore you must be afraid of God! For another, they say that God is unknowable; he is infinite and infinitely mysterious, so therefore you cannot know the mind of God or understand his ways.
These sentiments are half-baked in truth, however. For one, fearing the Lord does not mean being afraid of him. Fear, in this case, means respect and reverence, not "grim reaper coming to get me in the night" afraid. And second, we are beings of limited knowledge, not zero knowledge! Perhaps we cannot fully comprehend the mind of God, but this doesn't mean we can't know some of it! We can still study and learn of God's ways. To me, it is unacceptable to quit searching for answers and declare, "Oh well, I will never understand how God works. I guess I'll just live with what I know." Why not approach our fears of God and try to understand his true nature instead of trying to worship a God we are afraid of?
UPDATE: A day later, an opinion article was written in the Echo. Here is the summarizing paragraph:
This is perhaps true, but what I fear is the other extreme. I fear that people will grow (or already have grown) complacent with not knowing, instead relegating everything we don't understand to "God's mysterious ways." The truth doesn't have to be scary! There are many things that can be explained and comprehended! Yes, God is bigger than our intellect, but our intellect can be bigger than it is right now.
We went with our friends to church in the morning. First service, which we went to, is a very traditional service, whereas there are two second services--one traditional and one contemporary, but the same pastor preaches the same message for all the services (he's projected for the contemporary service). After first service, we participated in our friend's "Sunday School". The pre-Sunday-school conversation eventually drifted towards the technical (not my fault!) as people were discussing email and the like. What someone said caught my attention.
The gist of what she said is that she doesn't want to use Gmail anymore. The reason? "It's too creepy." I'll admit, I don't think I've ever heard that one before. She explained that Gmail now displayed ads that were related to the content of her email messages. (Actually, it has been that way for a long time.) The result? Creepiness. How does she know, for instance, that someone isn't sitting there reading her email messages and picking out advertisements that were relevant?
Well, of course, this is obviously silly. Except that, it is not obvious to some (perhaps many) people. If it were obviously silly, then there wouldn't be a problem! There are a number of issues that might come into play here, such as numerical estimation (How many emails are sent through Google per minute, and how long does it take to read the average email, and how long would it take to pick out relevant ads, so how many people would Google have to employ to perform this task?), cost-benefit analysis (If a person were being paid to read emails and deliver ads, how much would they be paid per hour versus how much profit would Google make out of people clicking on relevant advertising versus non-relevant advertising? Would it be worth it?), and sheer logical impossibility (Emails are delivered in a matter of seconds, much much faster than any human could possibly read the email and select ads to display next to it.) So, when you think about it, it is obviously silly to think that someone is actually sitting there reading your emails all day.
But for some reason it is still "creepy", perhaps because this person did not ever stop to think about it. And that is fine. Some people aren't very capable of estimating numbers, performing cost-benefit analysis, or thinking logically through a problem. I don't judge people for not being mathematically-minded. However, I am concerned about the outcome. When she noticed that Gmail was doing something strange and didn't understand the process, it engendered fear. This, I think, is the root of the problem, and is the point of my spiel.
Why does the unknown cause fear? Especially something so silly and small as our email privacy? This I do not fully understand. Personally, when I see something that doesn't work the way I think it should, I get curious. I ask myself, "Why does it behave like that?" and "How does it work?" and "What must I learn in order to better understand it?" This is because I realize that understanding is within the realm of possibility. For others, though, instead of raising their curious nature, they get afraid of what they don't understand.
So then what about God? It is no errant thing to say that many people are afraid of God, or the concept of God. Even many Christians are afraid of God for many reasons. If I don't "do things" just right, will I lose my salvation? What if I'm not saved? Have I angered God? Will I fall out of favor with him? What if I sin one too many times? Will I go to hell?
Furthermore, these things are preached from the pulpits. For one, they quote the proverb "The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom," so therefore you must be afraid of God! For another, they say that God is unknowable; he is infinite and infinitely mysterious, so therefore you cannot know the mind of God or understand his ways.
These sentiments are half-baked in truth, however. For one, fearing the Lord does not mean being afraid of him. Fear, in this case, means respect and reverence, not "grim reaper coming to get me in the night" afraid. And second, we are beings of limited knowledge, not zero knowledge! Perhaps we cannot fully comprehend the mind of God, but this doesn't mean we can't know some of it! We can still study and learn of God's ways. To me, it is unacceptable to quit searching for answers and declare, "Oh well, I will never understand how God works. I guess I'll just live with what I know." Why not approach our fears of God and try to understand his true nature instead of trying to worship a God we are afraid of?
UPDATE: A day later, an opinion article was written in the Echo. Here is the summarizing paragraph:
Perhaps the truth is scary because it cannot be easily explained. Like the end of the world, we may never know exactly how to quantify it, and when we try, we end up confining God to the extent of our understanding. The most humbling realization is that there are things about our lives we may never fully comprehend. That's where faith comes in.
This is perhaps true, but what I fear is the other extreme. I fear that people will grow (or already have grown) complacent with not knowing, instead relegating everything we don't understand to "God's mysterious ways." The truth doesn't have to be scary! There are many things that can be explained and comprehended! Yes, God is bigger than our intellect, but our intellect can be bigger than it is right now.
Friday, March 4, 2011
The Second Coming of Christ
Think about the second coming of Christ, as you have heard it, seen it on felt boards, or pictured it in your mind. It probably goes something like this:
Coming on the clouds, with trumpets, visible from all over the world. And then the rapture happens, where we either disappear instantly or ascend supernaturally into the sky to meet the Lord in the air.
Something like that.
Ask any Christian, and you'll get a similar answer. This is what the Bible teaches, does it not? Especially Revelation and that one passage in Matthew, and all the rest?
Dwell on it for a minute. Think about the time you read the first Left Behind book or (ashamedly) seen the movie. Remember Sunday School when you learned about it, or perhaps recall the last time your preacher preached on heaven, Revelation, or the rapture.
...
Now, put that on hold, and think about something else for a minute. Think about the first coming of Christ. What do we picture here? Baby Jesus, manger, shepherds, wise men, Bethlehem, no room at the inn, etc. Ah yes, Christmas time all over again.
To us, these things are obvious. We grew up with them. They make sense. But consider this: to whom will Christ be coming when he comes for a second time? Answer: Christians. Consider this as well: to whom did Christ come the FIRST time? Answer: The Jews.
But something was wrong with the Jews. Christ came for them, but they didn't recognize him. Indeed, they were very much expecting a Messiah who would deliver them, but they were expecting a great king to seize power from the government, free the people, and rule over them as God. They were not expecting a baby wrapped in a thin cloth in a horse manger while Caesar was taking a census. They were not expecting a mad man riding into Jerusalem on a donkey. That's just absurd.
But they thought they knew when their Messiah would come! They were sure of it! And when he came in a radically different way than they expected, they didn't recognize him, declared him a heretic, and had him tortured and killed. All because of their expectations.
So, I ask you, how do you know that Christ will come back on the clouds, and all will instantly recognize him? If the Old Testament prophecies were a symbolic representation of the manner of Christ's first coming, how do you know that our New Testament prophecies aren't a symbolic representation of the manner of Christ's second coming? Are you sure you'll be able to recognize him? Are you sure it'll happen the way you think it'll happen?
Coming on the clouds, with trumpets, visible from all over the world. And then the rapture happens, where we either disappear instantly or ascend supernaturally into the sky to meet the Lord in the air.
Something like that.
Ask any Christian, and you'll get a similar answer. This is what the Bible teaches, does it not? Especially Revelation and that one passage in Matthew, and all the rest?
Dwell on it for a minute. Think about the time you read the first Left Behind book or (ashamedly) seen the movie. Remember Sunday School when you learned about it, or perhaps recall the last time your preacher preached on heaven, Revelation, or the rapture.
...
Now, put that on hold, and think about something else for a minute. Think about the first coming of Christ. What do we picture here? Baby Jesus, manger, shepherds, wise men, Bethlehem, no room at the inn, etc. Ah yes, Christmas time all over again.
To us, these things are obvious. We grew up with them. They make sense. But consider this: to whom will Christ be coming when he comes for a second time? Answer: Christians. Consider this as well: to whom did Christ come the FIRST time? Answer: The Jews.
But something was wrong with the Jews. Christ came for them, but they didn't recognize him. Indeed, they were very much expecting a Messiah who would deliver them, but they were expecting a great king to seize power from the government, free the people, and rule over them as God. They were not expecting a baby wrapped in a thin cloth in a horse manger while Caesar was taking a census. They were not expecting a mad man riding into Jerusalem on a donkey. That's just absurd.
But they thought they knew when their Messiah would come! They were sure of it! And when he came in a radically different way than they expected, they didn't recognize him, declared him a heretic, and had him tortured and killed. All because of their expectations.
So, I ask you, how do you know that Christ will come back on the clouds, and all will instantly recognize him? If the Old Testament prophecies were a symbolic representation of the manner of Christ's first coming, how do you know that our New Testament prophecies aren't a symbolic representation of the manner of Christ's second coming? Are you sure you'll be able to recognize him? Are you sure it'll happen the way you think it'll happen?
Labels:
Christ,
expectation,
second coming of Christ
Lent
In an extraordinary measure of self-sacrifice, I believe I will choose to give up carrots for this upcoming Lent season.
Wednesday, March 2, 2011
On Alvin Plantinga's Discourse on "Truth and Worldviews"
"Alvin Plantinga is one of the most important and influential philosophers of the 20th and early 21st centuries. His publications range over a wide variety of fields, but his most enduring contributions have been in metaphysics, epistemology, and, especially the philosophy of religion." says the back of the little insert we got as a prize for walking into chapel. Sounds like just my kind of guy! Sounds like he knows everything! Perhaps I was expecting too much.
To be honest, I was quite disappointed by Plantinga's chapel message this morning. I was expecting that he would give us some new insights into philosophy and religion, but I got nothing new. In fact, the entire time of his speech can be summed up as follows (substitute for "bad", "incompatible with Christianity" [his words]):
1. Naturalism is bad.
2. Anti-realism, though different, is also bad.
3. Anti-realism leads to relativism, which is bad because it doesn't make sense.
That's it. That's all he said. He used impressive vocabulary and defined his terms well, but his method of discourse was surely lacking.
Side note: What are these things? Naturalism says that the physical universe is all that is (i.e., there is no God). Anti-realism says that mankind is the author/architect of the known universe (anything that is, is because of us). Relativism, according to him, says that there is no absolute truth ("Truth is collectively or individually constructed.").
He then throws out some statistics that say that most people don't believe in absolute truth, and then makes this statement:
"But obviously this is crazy."
Then later:
"How does [relativism] fit with Christian belief? Very badly."
Just a statement, nothing more. No explanation, no Biblical support, and despite being a world-renowned philosopher, no philosophical support. He just claims that relativism "doesn't make sense" and declares it "incompatible with Christianity."
But why? Did he even think about it? I would think that he has, but he certainly gave no indication of it today. If relativism is "obviously" crazy, then why do the majority ascribe to it? Does that mean that 66% of adults and 72% of those aged 18-25 are crazy, or mentally ill?
I would consider myself part-naturalist, part-anti-realist, part-relativist, and yet still a God-believer, and it all makes sense to me! True, pure relativism might not make a whole lot of sense, but you've got to do better than just claiming that it doesn't make sense. The question is why doesn't it make sense? Give us some proofs, or arguments based on anecdotal evidence at least! Consider this:
With respect to science and humanities, I am a naturalist. I believe that God created the universe, but I do not think that you have to believe that God created the universe in order to study it, learn from it, and better yourself through it. There are plenty of atheist and Christian scientists all working to make the world a better place.
With respect to human endeavors, I am anti-realist. God didn't put us on the moon...we put ourselves on the moon! God didn't develop the polio vaccine...we did! Does God take a back seat to our endeavors and leave us to our own devices? Certainly not! I don't deny that God is here, and that he is actively doing stuff, but we humans nevertheless accomplish things, sometimes good and many times evil. We may not have created the universe, but God did leave it to us to cultivate it, use it, and architect it as we see fit.
With respect to truth, I am both a relativist and, well, whatever the opposite of a relativist is. There is both absolute truth and there is relative truth. For the relativist, we needn't look further than the laws of science to find absolute truth: What goes up must come down. Like forces repel. For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. These are truth. For Plantinga et.al., we needn't look further than the Bible to find relative truth! Consider one of my favorite passages, Romans 14:
"I know and am convinced in the Lord Jesus that there is nothing unclean in itself; still, it is unclean to the one who considers it unclean." (14:14)
What is Paul saying here? He is saying that there are those who ascribe to the old Jewish laws and consider certain foods unclean, and there are those who deny the old laws and declare all foods clean. For the one, it is sin to eat of unclean food, but for the other, it is only sin to be a stumbling block to the one who won't eat unclean food. (Some) sin is relative! Paul is convicted that no food is unclean, but he won't cause another to stumble by eating that food in front of them. But is it actually sin or just the perception of sin? Paul says:
"The faith you have, keep to yourself before God. Blessed is the one who does not judge himself by what he approves. But the man who doubts is condemned if he eats, because he does not do so from faith, and whatever is not from faith is sin." (14:22-23)
So yes! The very same act that is sin for one person is not sin for another person. In this case, the sinfulness of the action is relative to the person doing the action. (Though, you could argue that the sin lies not in the eating of unclean food, but rather by doing something against your convictions or by doing something not from faith. In this case, the sin is therefore not relative because it is internally judged according to one's convictions instead of externally judged according to one's actions. However, all the examples that Plantinga gave during his message were of external actions, such as poverty, war, lying, and "other ills", and his message seemed to be very externally-focused.)
What is the point of my diatribe? I suppose the main point I would like to make is that it is wrong to just make a statement and proclaim it as truth. Plantinga, a world-renowned philosopher, ought to do better than just saying that relativism is incompatible with Christianity and leave it at that. What if he's wrong? What is his reasoning? Does his statement stand up to criticism? Is he able to rebut a rebuttal? We don't know, because he didn't address those things. I feel like every single Monday-Wednesday-Friday-Sunday is like this. Are we Christians afraid of criticism? If not, then where's the criticism that should be there?
To be honest, I was quite disappointed by Plantinga's chapel message this morning. I was expecting that he would give us some new insights into philosophy and religion, but I got nothing new. In fact, the entire time of his speech can be summed up as follows (substitute for "bad", "incompatible with Christianity" [his words]):
1. Naturalism is bad.
2. Anti-realism, though different, is also bad.
3. Anti-realism leads to relativism, which is bad because it doesn't make sense.
That's it. That's all he said. He used impressive vocabulary and defined his terms well, but his method of discourse was surely lacking.
Side note: What are these things? Naturalism says that the physical universe is all that is (i.e., there is no God). Anti-realism says that mankind is the author/architect of the known universe (anything that is, is because of us). Relativism, according to him, says that there is no absolute truth ("Truth is collectively or individually constructed.").
He then throws out some statistics that say that most people don't believe in absolute truth, and then makes this statement:
"But obviously this is crazy."
Then later:
"How does [relativism] fit with Christian belief? Very badly."
Just a statement, nothing more. No explanation, no Biblical support, and despite being a world-renowned philosopher, no philosophical support. He just claims that relativism "doesn't make sense" and declares it "incompatible with Christianity."
But why? Did he even think about it? I would think that he has, but he certainly gave no indication of it today. If relativism is "obviously" crazy, then why do the majority ascribe to it? Does that mean that 66% of adults and 72% of those aged 18-25 are crazy, or mentally ill?
I would consider myself part-naturalist, part-anti-realist, part-relativist, and yet still a God-believer, and it all makes sense to me! True, pure relativism might not make a whole lot of sense, but you've got to do better than just claiming that it doesn't make sense. The question is why doesn't it make sense? Give us some proofs, or arguments based on anecdotal evidence at least! Consider this:
With respect to science and humanities, I am a naturalist. I believe that God created the universe, but I do not think that you have to believe that God created the universe in order to study it, learn from it, and better yourself through it. There are plenty of atheist and Christian scientists all working to make the world a better place.
With respect to human endeavors, I am anti-realist. God didn't put us on the moon...we put ourselves on the moon! God didn't develop the polio vaccine...we did! Does God take a back seat to our endeavors and leave us to our own devices? Certainly not! I don't deny that God is here, and that he is actively doing stuff, but we humans nevertheless accomplish things, sometimes good and many times evil. We may not have created the universe, but God did leave it to us to cultivate it, use it, and architect it as we see fit.
With respect to truth, I am both a relativist and, well, whatever the opposite of a relativist is. There is both absolute truth and there is relative truth. For the relativist, we needn't look further than the laws of science to find absolute truth: What goes up must come down. Like forces repel. For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction. These are truth. For Plantinga et.al., we needn't look further than the Bible to find relative truth! Consider one of my favorite passages, Romans 14:
"I know and am convinced in the Lord Jesus that there is nothing unclean in itself; still, it is unclean to the one who considers it unclean." (14:14)
What is Paul saying here? He is saying that there are those who ascribe to the old Jewish laws and consider certain foods unclean, and there are those who deny the old laws and declare all foods clean. For the one, it is sin to eat of unclean food, but for the other, it is only sin to be a stumbling block to the one who won't eat unclean food. (Some) sin is relative! Paul is convicted that no food is unclean, but he won't cause another to stumble by eating that food in front of them. But is it actually sin or just the perception of sin? Paul says:
"The faith you have, keep to yourself before God. Blessed is the one who does not judge himself by what he approves. But the man who doubts is condemned if he eats, because he does not do so from faith, and whatever is not from faith is sin." (14:22-23)
So yes! The very same act that is sin for one person is not sin for another person. In this case, the sinfulness of the action is relative to the person doing the action. (Though, you could argue that the sin lies not in the eating of unclean food, but rather by doing something against your convictions or by doing something not from faith. In this case, the sin is therefore not relative because it is internally judged according to one's convictions instead of externally judged according to one's actions. However, all the examples that Plantinga gave during his message were of external actions, such as poverty, war, lying, and "other ills", and his message seemed to be very externally-focused.)
What is the point of my diatribe? I suppose the main point I would like to make is that it is wrong to just make a statement and proclaim it as truth. Plantinga, a world-renowned philosopher, ought to do better than just saying that relativism is incompatible with Christianity and leave it at that. What if he's wrong? What is his reasoning? Does his statement stand up to criticism? Is he able to rebut a rebuttal? We don't know, because he didn't address those things. I feel like every single Monday-Wednesday-Friday-Sunday is like this. Are we Christians afraid of criticism? If not, then where's the criticism that should be there?



