Pages

Friday, February 25, 2011

Emotion

What is the purpose of emotion?

Why was it created?

What good does it serve?

What evil does it serve?

Is emotion the logical converse of intellect?  If not, how do they fit together?

Does emotion in worship help us or distract us in growing closer to God?

What does it mean to "grow closer to God", anyways?  Is this something we should even be doing?  Is this a purely emotional concept, a purely intellectual concept, or a mixture of both?

Intellect is the logical study of truth.  Emotion is directly related to the hormones raging through your body in response to internal and external stimuli.  Are these things equally valid?

Intellect, when used properly, should never lie or be deceiving.  Emotion, on the other hand, cannot by definition be "used properly" -- it just is.  It can reveal truth and it can deceive, and it is sometimes very difficult to tell the two apart.  There is no good system for knowing when emotion is lying or not.  (Except, of course, by using intellect.)

Being intellectual is something we do, whereas being emotional is something we are.  No one practices their emotions, but we must practice our intellectual capabilities if they are to grow.  (If anything, people have to practice restraining their emotions, but I've never heard of a case where someone practiced being more emotional.  Perhaps our species is inherently too emotional and not intellectual enough, so we must practice restraining one and nurturing the other?)

In light of all these differences, are intellect and emotion even comparable?  Are they the same type of thing?  Is it possible to have both, or are they mutually exclusive?

And here, perhaps, is the ultimate question: If it is possible to use intellect to know right from wrong etc. and to know the truth of God, is it also possible to use emotion to know right from wrong etc. and to know the truth of God?


Just some of the things I think about every now and then.  I like to ask questions.  But if anyone can answer even one of these questions, then PLEASE tell me!  I might even buy you a sundae at Ivanhoe's.

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Scientology

Yesterday I started reading a very long article on Scientology from an ex-Scientologist's (Paul Haggis) perspective.


Privately, he told me, he remained troubled by the church’s theology, which struck him as “intergalactic spirituality.” He was grateful, however, to have an auditor who was “really smart, sweet, thoughtful. I could always go to talk to him.” The confessionals were helpful. “It just felt better to get things off my chest.” Even after his incredulous reaction to O.T. III, he continued to “move up” the Bridge. He saw so many intelligent people on the path, and expected that his concerns would be addressed in future levels. He told himself, “Maybe there is something, and I’m just missing it.” He felt unsettled by the lack of irony among many fellow-Scientologists—an inability to laugh at themselves, which seemed at odds with the character of Hubbard himself. When Haggis felt doubts about the religion, he recalled 16-mm. films he had seen of Hubbard’s lectures from the fifties and sixties. “He had this amazing buoyancy,” Haggis says. “He had a deadpan humor and this sense of himself that seemed to say, ‘Yes, I am fully aware that I might be mad, but I also might be on to something.’ ”

Haggis finally reached the top of the Operating Thetan pyramid. According to documents obtained by WikiLeaks, the activist group run by Julian Assange, the final exercise is: “Go out to a park, train station or other busy area. Practice placing an intention into individuals until you can successfully and easily place an intention into or on a Being and/or a body.”


Haggis expected that, as an O.T. VII, he would feel a sense of accomplishment, but he remained confused and unsatisfied. He thought that Hubbard was “brilliant in so many ways,” and that the failing must be his. At one point, he confided to a minister in the church that he didn’t think he should be a Scientologist. She told him, “There are all sorts of Scientologists,” just as there are all sorts of Jews and Christians, with varying levels of faith. The implication, Haggis said, was that he could “pick and choose” which tenets of Scientology to believe.

Substitute "Scientology" with "Christianity", "Hubbard" with "Jesus", and "auditors" with "pastors", and this is kinda how I felt sometimes about Christianity.  For a long time, I thought I was just "missing something" and that it would all make sense if only I was more spiritual, or read my Bible and prayed more, or went to church more.  I questioned some of the stranger things in Christianity but was told that the paradoxes didn't matter, and that you could still believe everything despite the paradoxes.  I wondered why, like Haggis' fellow Scientologists, Christians seemed to have an inability to laugh at themselves and critique themselves.  "Why must we always be so uptight about everything?" I asked.

Universalism may have been declared heretical, but it resolves the paradoxes and makes perfect rational sense.  Questioning things and having doubts about your faith may be discouraged, but I feel like that is the only thing separating the Christian faith from the Christian cult.  How will we learn if we don't ask questions?  How will we ever make ourselves better if we can't critique ourselves?  How can we prevent being tied to a cultic system like the Scientologists are tied to theirs, with no room for outside inquiry or constructive criticism?

I Reject Your God

I reject your God.

If your God consigns tens of billions of people to eternal suffering and torture because of unfortunate circumstances or because they didn't pray a specific prayer, then I reject your God.

If your God requires me to hate anyone, like unbelievers, gays, democrats, or murderers, then I reject your God.

If your God requires me to commit genocide in his name, then I reject your God.

If your God requires me to abandon science and reason, then I reject your God.

If your God requires me to preach a so-called “gospel” of death, suffering, evil, and hopelessness, then I reject your God.

If your God requires a sufficient display of “good works” on my part before he will impart salvation, then I reject your God.

If your God is small enough to require enough faith in him before he will save my soul, then I reject your God.

If such a God exists, then he is not worthy of my worship or respect, and I reject his supposed sovereignty over the world and over my life.



I am free from your god.

I am free to believe in a God who loves each and every person that he has created.

I am free to believe in a God who desires the eternal salvation of all mankind.

I am free to believe in a God who is powerful enough to bring about the ultimate good he desires.

I am free to believe in a God who loves me unconditionally, despite my doubts and my sins.

I am free to believe in a God who makes sense.

I am free to preach a gospel of faith, repentance, life, joy, and hope for all mankind.

I am free to love every creature of God's creation, just as he loved them first.

I am free to love myself.

I am free to put all my trust in a God who will never abandon me, who will never let go of my soul for any reason, and who is truly deserving of the respect and worship that I bring.

I am free.


*cue Newsboys*

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

The Church

Raise your Bible over your head if anyone has ever asked you where you go to church.  Yeah, it's happened to all of us, especially us college-age kids.


This question made complete sense as I grew up.  If you're a Christian, you go to church.  That's just what you do.  No one explained how or why, but church is the place you go to on Sunday mornings to sing songs and hear the pastor talk about something.  It was never fun, and I was always much happier when it was over.  And this is from a guy who isn't too picky about his circumstances.  I mean, I liked going to the dentist but I hated going to church!  This was still true throughout college and is still true today.  Getting up earlier than you'd like to drive to a building filled with a bunch of strangers while you sing songs and get emotional and listen to some random guy talk about who-knows-what from the Bible and then feeling guilty about it is NOT COOL.


I challenge this.  I challenge not only the fact that church is boring and un-fun but also the very idea that it makes logical sense to go to church at all.  I claim that it is ridiculous to even talk about "attending church" or asking someone else where they "go to church".


What is the church?  I feel like our modern culture has warped the definition of "church" so much that it would look completely foreign to Jesus and his disciples.  To them, our churches today would be the tabernacles of their time.  But Jesus came to show us that God doesn't live in tabernacles!  Jesus showed us that we can find and approach God anywhere, not just in a religious building!  Moreover, Jesus came to establish the Church, the Ekklesia, that is not anyone anywhere but rather is everyone everywhere!  The Church isn't some building or service...it is you and me and all those who together glorify and worship God!  We needn't be a member of a denomination or a regular patron of an entertainment institution to be able to learn about God and grow closer to him.


Churches exist to fill a social void.  When they succeed, that's great, but I don't think I have ever learned anything about God by singing songs or listening to sermons.  This may be because I learn by actively doing, and church is simply a pedagogy of passive intake, "in one ear and out the other" as my teachers liked to say.  I succeeded at math and science because I got to do those things.  History and literature never made sense because I couldn't actually do them, and as a result I didn't care.


I also don't care anymore that singing upbeat songs gets my endorphins flowing.  I'm not depressed anymore and I get all the emotions I need from being with my wife, so I don't need it from church.  Now that I actually care about knowing God instead of filling an emotional void, I want to learn more about God beyond basic sunday school lessons, and that doesn't happen during church sermons.  I want more!


Instead, I've found other avenues to grow and learn.  I am learning Greek from my friend and am starting to translate verses, dig into the original purpose of the Biblical authors, write commentaries, and analyze the finer and broader points of theology.  Shortly, we are planning on continuing my Greek studies while translating and studying the book of Romans.  I love discussing philosophy and theology with people.  I've refined my doctrine to the point of logical consistency (finally!) and now I want to share it with the world!


I like eating lunches and dinners with friends and discussing the not-so-finer things in life, like the latest Linux kernel patch or the Green Bay Packers.  In the past few weeks and months, I have learned so much more about my old and new friends, hosted and contributed to games and parties, rejoiced with my joyous friends, and mourned with my mourning friends.


This is the church.  This is how it feels to grow closer to God.  If going to a church building on Sunday morning does that for you, then I am genuinely happy for (and a little jealous of) you.  Many people are deluded on Sunday mornings by their version of church, thinking they are earning God's favor by attending their denomination's worship service, but many people have also found true intentional Christian community in a place like that.  Which camp are you in, honestly?  If you are in the former, then how can you break the guilt cycle of going to church just because you "should" and instead find meaningful community in the Church that Jesus came to establish?

Friday, January 28, 2011

Reaching Out

I recently read a blog post that explains very well where Christians go wrong in trying to "convert" people, and where unbelievers go wrong in trying to "deconvert" them.  The author of this post describes her conversion experience as a slow, step-by-step process:

It wasn’t arguments, persuasive or otherwise, that got me to either one of the extremes. It wasn’t proofs and reports. It wasn’t people railing against what I believed. It was hearing and listening, little bits at a time. It was done in my own time. It was opening doors, just a crack here and there, testing things out. It was seeking out confirmation other peoples’ experience, through books and websites. It was two steps forward and one step back.


You can’t whack people over the head and expect them to change immediately. You can’t try to argue them out of a corner they have painted themselves into. You can’t force the truth onto them. It takes awhile to change a mindset. I had to overcome internal resistance to the fact that I might be wrong. This is never easy. To admit I might be wrong takes courage, even if I am just admitting it to myself.


So don’t lambaste, don’t rail, don’t argue. Don’t try to force the door open because what will happen is that [they], with their integrity at stake, with their whole belief system and world view in jeopardy will lock that door with multiple locks, they will jam a chair up under the doorknob, they will alert the authorities that someone is trying to force their way in and they will close themselves off even more.


Instead, try some compassion. Remember that a lot of us were there at one time, too. Make suggestions. Offer different ways of looking at things. Be an example. Share your story. Instead of trying to force the door open, slip a little note under the door. Maybe they will read it, if not now, then later. [Theresa, 2007]


I think where we get into trouble is when we try to argue our position and never get past that point.  Yes, formal debate is wholesome and valuable, but most of the time we are not involved in formal debate.  Most of the time, we are interacting with others and building relationships with them.  If the majority of what we do is argue, how does that help our case?  Perhaps we should be less prone to judging and more prone to being neighborly with those whom we disagree with.  Experience has shown me that that is the best way to reach out to others.

Sunday, January 23, 2011

Happiness of Joy

I pulled the following verbatim from a friend's blog, as it is a very wise observation about our source of joy:

I read through a friend's blog post recently that contrasts the differences of happiness and joy. Travis writes: "A good life can't rely on places, jobs, or people for hope and confidence... that would be like relying on scratch lotto tickets for a stable financial future".

Happiness is circumstantial. Circumstances that are unpleasant are most often out of our control. Joy is more of a foundation. A foundation that gauges our reactions and satisfactions. A foundation based of our faith and beliefs. Joy is the hope of knowing an outcome to an unpleasant circumstance.

Joy based on the wrong beliefs is not joyful, even under happy circumstances. Read Ecclesiastes 2:1-17. Uncountable happy circumstances only resulted in an astounding grievous response.

Now read Nehemiah 8:10. Mainly the part about "do not be grieved, for the joy of the LORD is your strength". This is a command, do not! Do not grieve, why not? Because the LORD is the foundation of our joy, and the foundation is secure. This is written in Nehemiah in a time that the Israelites had been in captivity. Read that as an unpleasant circumstance. Even in times of distress one can have joy if their foundation is secure.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Commentary: Matthew 16:18

Matthew 16:18 is an interesting verse.  I've heard lots of interpretations of it and lots of interesting theology drawn from it.  (For example, Catholic tradition uses this verse to lay the doctrine that Peter is the first Pope, a position given to him by Christ himself during this dialogue.  Evangelicals, of course, like to say other things.)

The main argument by Evangelicals is that, since the text says "the gates of Hell shall not prevail against [the church]," that must mean that the church ought to be on the offensive against the powers of Hell, instead of just standing by and idly defending itself from accusation. The intended emotion that pastors like to stir up by using this verse is excitement and resolve—a call to action.

But I question if we can really get that kind of theology from this verse.  If God really wanted us to "go to war," as it were, I imagine it would be a major theme of the New Testament instead of relegated to the subtext behind a sole half of a verse.  Certainly, there are instances where God's people take up arms against their opponents, but isn't Jesus' life characterized by passive resistance and humble silence, for example, when being interrogated by the Sanhedrin?

I would like to propose an alternate interpretation of this verse based on a reading of the original text.  And in so doing, there are three important things to consider.

  1. First, the word translated Hell in the original Greek is actually hades.  In the Septuagint, the word sheol (grave) is translated into the Greek as hades, indicating that this is a place where all dead were sent, both righteous and unrighteous.  Sheol is first and foremost a place of separation from God.  The concepts of the immortality of the soul and reward and punishment in hades began later in rabbinic Judea.  The word hades occurs only ten times in the New Testament, described as a place within the earth, a prison with gates—the key to which is held by Jesus Christ, and a place which will, one day, give up its dead.  According to Acts 2:27,31, the dead, including Jesus Christ, are sent to hades; but, according to his promise, God raised Christ from the dead (that is, hades) so that his body would not "experience decay." [Information paraphrased from the New International Dictionary of New Testament Theology, Abridged Edition, by Verbrugge.]
  2. The Greek word that is translated as "prevail against" is katischuo.  This word can take several meanings, among them "to be strong to another's detriment," "to prevail against," "to be superior in strength," or "to overcome."  The Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd edition, by Danker and Bauer, defines katischusousin in the context of Matthew 16:18 as "to have the capability to defeat, win a victory over."  (Katischusousin is the form of the word katischuo that actually appears in the text.) In fact, the KJV renders this word as "prevail against," but most other translations render it as "will overcome."  It stands to reason, then, that it is not the intention of the author that hades is unable to withstand the onslaught of the church, but simply that it will not ultimately prove stronger or more powerful than it.  It is not clear from the text who exactly is supposed to be "on the offensive" against the other.
  3. Above all, if we were to translate it as a call to arms against Hell, who would we really be fighting?  Who created Hell?  Who is going to Hell?  Popular Christian doctrine tells us that Satan is the creator, sustainer, and "leader" of Hell, but this is not so!  No, God is the creator of everything, both good and evil, heaven and Hell.  Satan does not rule over Hell; indeed, Hell was created especially for him, for that is where he will be "tormented there day and night forever and ever" (see Rev. 20:7-10).  Jesus himself holds the keys to Hell.  An attack against Hell would be an attack against its Creator, that is, God, and the justice he chooses to bring against those who are sent there.
In conclusion, the words of Jesus in this verse do not necessarily imply that the church must go "on the offensive" against the forces of Hell.  Rather, the text simply says that death and despair will prove to be no match for the Church that Jesus is building, starting with Peter.  No matter who is on the offensive, God will ultimately rise victorious.

Special thanks to David C. for assisting with this commentary.