The second part of the chapter deals with how the Bible was formed (i.e., how the canon was developed). It is here that McDowell betrays his own bias. He says,
It is important to note that the church did not create the canon; it did not determine which books would be called Scripture, the inspired Word of God. Instead, the church recognized, or discovered, which books had been inspired from their inception. Stated another way, a book is not the Word of God because it is accepted by the people of God. Rather, it was accepted by the people of God because it is the Word of God. That is, God gives the book its divine authority, not the people of God.Of course you will conclude that God is real and the Bible is valid if you start with the assumption that God is real and the Bible is valid! This circular argument only carries weight if you already believe in God and the divine inspiration of Scripture. But a person who honestly questions these assumptions will find no basis for faith in faith itself. McDowell's clearly circular reasoning undermines any points he tries to make, but for the sake of reading what he has to say, I will continue.
The books that were selected for the NT canon were decided according to a test of apostolic authority (which seems to contradict his earlier suggestion that books were not selected, but discovered, to have been written by divine inspiration).
In a "response" to my query about the NT Apocrypha, McDowell cites Geisler and Nix (as he seems to do for all of his information thus far) concerning the reasons for the rejection of these books:
- They were only temporarily or locally recognized.
- They never had more than a semi-canonical status. (Though, what canonical books had more than a semi-canonical status before they were canonized?)
- No major canon or church council included them as inspired books of the NT. (Obviously, no major canon included them, so they were never canonized! This is not only the same argument as #2, but it is a tautology and essentially meaningless.)
- They were only popular because they connected themselves with the canonical books by claiming to have been written by them.
Prima facie, these arguments seem to argue well for the rejection of the NT Apocrypha. However, upon close examination, we see that arguments 2 and 3 are the same and meaningless. (They were never canonized because they were never included in the canon!) This is not a strawman argument on my part unless McDowell (or anyone) can clarify more precisely what they mean by these statements and show how these apocryphal books were somehow different or of a lesser origin as to not make the cut. (And, it should be noted, "divine inspiration" is simply begging the question.) Argument 1 can simply be attributed as a result of their non-canonicity, unless it can be shown that they became substantially less popular before the canon was created (in which case, why was their inclusion debatable?). Even so, it does not prove anything. Anyone can make a list of the 10 most popular books of their time on a specific subject. How does this prove the existence of God? Argument 4 is an explanation for their achieved popularity, but it does not actually differentiate between their kind of popularity and the kind of popularity that the canonized texts enjoyed. How are they different?
All that to say, McDowell answers some questions pertaining to how the Apocrypha was rejected, but not why. What were the thought processes of the people deciding what books to include and which to exclude? When faced with a potential candidate, how did they decide to which category it belonged? If they simply prayed about it and cast lots, then this is again begging the question. If they investigated the authorship of it and discovered that it was written only so the author could "get rich quick," whereas the canonical scriptures were actually written by authentic Christian leaders, then we would have a real metric that would be fairly convincing. But all McDowell presents are four entirely unconvincing "arguments" that require extreme clarification and/or additional research.
McDowell then spends much space focusing on the OT Apocrypha, a summary of those books, and reasons for their rejection. While I don't care so much about these, the reason he gives here are mostly satisfactory. Some arguments are very valid ("They abound in historical and geographical inaccuracies and anachronisms.") and some are stupid ("They teach doctrines that are false and foster practices that are at variance with inspired Scripture." ...this is essentially saying, "They were rejected as Scripture because they weren't Scripture!")
He finally concludes with yet another quote, "No Christian, confident in the providential working of his God and informed about the true nature of canonicity of his Word, should be disturbed about the dependability of the Bible we now possess." Frankly, I am disturbed about the quality of arguments that McDowell uses to defend the Biblical canon.
So far, I am not convinced.
