Pages

Sunday, October 9, 2011

New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 3 - Is the New Testament Historically Reliable? - Part 1

McDowell gives three criteria for establishing the reliability of the NT: the bibliographic test, the internal evidence test, and the external evidence test.


The bibliographic test argues that our extant copies of the NT is reliable because of the method and timeline with which they were passed down:

  • Our earliest extant copies of significant portions are "very close" in time to the date of their writing (250-300 years).
  • The number of extant manuscripts of the NT are great in number (counts vary but average around 5600).
  • Errors due to scribal errors and deliberate misinterpretations are minor, and no disputed passage influences central Christian doctrine. (Though, I would argue that you would have to define "central Christian doctrine" very narrowly for this to apply; say, the doctrine of the Apostle's Creed, which is a fair standard.)
  • There are various versions in different languages.
  • There are a plethora of quotes of the NT from early church fathers.
Much of his argument here is summarized in yet another quote (I am finding that over 50% of this book is quotes from other people.): "Since scholars accept as generally trustworthy the writings of the ancient classics even though the earliest MSS were written so long after the original writings and the number of extant MSS is in many instances so small, it is clear that the reliability of the text of the N.T. is likewise assured." Of course, this is true, all other things being equal. I would not be so bold as to say that all other considerations are equal, seeing as how early Christianity was fraught with rivalries and heresies and arguments. It cannot be disputed that the NT was very controversial, and it seems to me that this fact alone would give many people reason to be altered. Nevertheless, I will cede the point to McDowell (or, rather, the people he quotes).

Wednesday, September 28, 2011

New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 2 - How We God the Bible - Part 1

The first part of this chapter deals with specifications about the creation of the Bible, such as what writing materials were used and what the different forms of books were in ancient times. I'll assume that all this information is accurate.

The second part of the chapter deals with how the Bible was formed (i.e., how the canon was developed). It is here that McDowell betrays his own bias. He says,
It is important to note that the church did not create the canon; it did not determine which books would be called Scripture, the inspired Word of God. Instead, the church recognized, or discovered, which books had been inspired from their inception. Stated another way, a book is not the Word of God because it is accepted by the people of God. Rather, it was accepted by the people of God because it is the Word of God. That is, God gives the book its divine authority, not the people of God.
Of course you will conclude that God is real and the Bible is valid if you start with the assumption that God is real and the Bible is valid! This circular argument only carries weight if you already believe in God and the divine inspiration of Scripture. But a person who honestly questions these assumptions will find no basis for faith in faith itself. McDowell's clearly circular reasoning undermines any points he tries to make, but for the sake of reading what he has to say, I will continue.

The books that were selected for the NT canon were decided according to a test of apostolic authority (which seems to contradict his earlier suggestion that books were not selected, but discovered, to have been written by divine inspiration).

In a "response" to my query about the NT Apocrypha, McDowell cites Geisler and Nix (as he seems to do for all of his information thus far) concerning the reasons for the rejection of these books:

  1. They were only temporarily or locally recognized.
  2. They never had more than a semi-canonical status. (Though, what canonical books had more than a semi-canonical status before they were canonized?)
  3. No major canon or church council included them as inspired books of the NT. (Obviously, no major canon included them, so they were never canonized! This is not only the same argument as #2, but it is a tautology and essentially meaningless.)
  4. They were only popular because they connected themselves with the canonical books by claiming to have been written by them.
Prima facie, these arguments seem to argue well for the rejection of the NT Apocrypha. However, upon close examination, we see that arguments 2 and 3 are the same and meaningless. (They were never canonized because they were never included in the canon!) This is not a strawman argument on my part unless McDowell (or anyone) can clarify more precisely what they mean by these statements and show how these apocryphal books were somehow different or of a lesser origin as to not make the cut. (And, it should be noted, "divine inspiration" is simply begging the question.) Argument 1 can simply be attributed as a result of their non-canonicity, unless it can be shown that they became substantially less popular before the canon was created (in which case, why was their inclusion debatable?). Even so, it does not prove anything. Anyone can make a list of the 10 most popular books of their time on a specific subject. How does this prove the existence of God? Argument 4 is an explanation for their achieved popularity, but it does not actually differentiate between their kind of popularity and the kind of popularity that the canonized texts enjoyed. How are they different?

All that to say, McDowell answers some questions pertaining to how the Apocrypha was rejected, but not why. What were the thought processes of the people deciding what books to include and which to exclude? When faced with a potential candidate, how did they decide to which category it belonged? If they simply prayed about it and cast lots, then this is again begging the question. If they investigated the authorship of it and discovered that it was written only so the author could "get rich quick," whereas the canonical scriptures were actually written by authentic Christian leaders, then we would have a real metric that would be fairly convincing. But all McDowell presents are four entirely unconvincing "arguments" that require extreme clarification and/or additional research.

McDowell then spends much space focusing on the OT Apocrypha, a summary of those books, and reasons for their rejection. While I don't care so much about these, the reason he gives here are mostly satisfactory. Some arguments are very valid ("They abound in historical and geographical inaccuracies and anachronisms.") and some are stupid ("They teach doctrines that are false and foster practices that are at variance with inspired Scripture." ...this is essentially saying, "They were rejected as Scripture because they weren't Scripture!")

He finally concludes with yet another quote, "No Christian, confident in the providential working of his God and informed about the true nature of canonicity of his Word, should be disturbed about the dependability of the Bible we now possess." Frankly, I am disturbed about the quality of arguments that McDowell uses to defend the Biblical canon.

So far, I am not convinced.

Friday, September 23, 2011

New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 1 - The Uniqueness of the Bible

I probably won't comment as much on this chapter, because it appears to be basically the same as the first chapter from the previous book, with no new major sections. It still stands that the main point McDowell is making is, "The Bible is unique among religious books, so that makes it worthy of attention." But of course, every religious text is unique, and the Bible shares more in common with them than McDowell is willing to admit. It is simply a non sequitur to claim that uniqueness implies specialness.

He did change one sentence in his conclusion that I would like to draw attention to. Instead of saying, "The above does not prove the Bible is the Word of God, but to me it proves that it is unique," he says, "The evidence presented above does not prove that the Bible is the Word of God. But to me it clearly indicates that it is uniquely superior to any and all other books." While I could admit to his original statement, his revision is superbly elitist and plays directly into my rebuttal. No, unless you first assume that God exists and is like who you think he is like, then you cannot jump from "the Bible is unique" to "the Bible is superior to all other books." This is plain intellectual dishonesty.

So far, I am not impressed.

New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Introduction

As it turns out, McDowell's book The New Evidence That Demands a Verdict is simply an edited and compiled version of his previous two books. This thing is a beast. I'm thinking I should take a slow and steady approach to it, like one chapter a week. In a couple weeks I will be receiving Dawkin's new book, The Magic of Reality: How We Know What's Really True, and I will want to review this book too (as I eventually want to review Keller's The Reason for God and give it a thorough rereading). So much to do, so little time! Compound this with the fact that I am now addicted to Minecraft, and we have a real problem here...

At any rate, I started skimming the introduction to New Evidence, and while I am not giving it a thorough reading, there are a couple of differences I noticed.

McDowell spends a lengthy section discussion the problem with postmodern deconstructionism. While I do agree that contemporary thought is pervaded by a sense of postmodernism, I think that there is a healthy balance of modernism and postmodernism. Too much of one philosophy causes problems. So, without really reading his section, I'll just assume that I agree with him for the most part.

He also examines some logical issues surrounding Eastern mysticism, but since I am about as far from Eastern religions as I can be, I don't feel the need to visit this topic.

McDowell added something, I believe, to his section on Atheism. This is what he says (sorry, quotes): "Sartre found atheism 'cruel,' Camus 'dreadful,' and Nietzsche 'maddening.' Atheists who consistently try to live without God tend to commit suicide or go insane. Those who are inconsistent live on the ethical or aesthetic shadow of Christian truth while they deny the reality that made the shadow." This is absolutely, unequivocally false! Where do I even begin? First of all, to call on Sartre, Camus, and Nietzsche as the representative voices of all atheists is utterly disingenuous. They had massive philosophical and personal issues that do not apply to many, many people. Second, to claim that all atheists who are happy are only happy because of Christianity is completely dishonest to the discussion (if there is one). The point here is to question and critique Christianity, not assume it to be true! Comments like this make me wonder if McDowell is really taking an honest step back or if he is just trying to reassure people who are already Christians who are having doubts, for it does nothing to convince a nonbeliever.

He then discusses agnosticism, and makes several logical fallacies. McDowell seems to be indicating that agnosticism is an alternative to atheism, when in fact they are compatible. I should know, for I am both! A theist is someone who actively believes in a deity; an atheist is someone who actively disbelieves in a deity; an agnostic is someone who believes that absolute certainty about knowledge is unattainable. Most of us are agnostics, and this is something I've come to learn about the world from a very young age. It is not possible to know with absolute certainty that the sun will rise tomorrow, let alone that there is an invisible undetectable supernatural deity. I still believe that the sun will rise, and I have a mountain of evidence pointing to the fact that it will, but I can't claim to know it for sure. Likewise, I am an agnostic atheist. I disbelieve in a deity, but I don't claim to know this with 100% certainty. McDowell counters, "The fundamental flaw in Kant's hard agnostic position is his claim to have knowledge of what he declares to be unknowable. In other words, if it were true that reality cannot be known, no one, including Kant, would know it. Kant's hard agnosticism boils down to the claim: 'I know that reality is unknowable.' " But this isn't true! Now, I don't know what Kant would say, but I claim that, though reality is not ultimately certain, I still have a massive pile of evidence that points me in the direction of the truth. I may not know it 100%, but I do know it 99.9999999%, and that is enough statistical weight to allow me to live my life and claim to know something. There is a huge difference between "having no knowledge of reality" and "not having absolute certainty about reality." (In fact, somewhere in this introduction, McDowell even admits to being an agnostic theist! He says that he cannot prove for sure that God exists, but the evidence points him in that direction, so that is what he believes. As McDowell would say, case closed.)

Then begins the argument from "science." McDowell appeals to the classic argument against evolution by chance, the "obvious" need for an intelligent designer, and some ludicrous false statements about the nature of the universe. The science in this section is so badly done, I am disgusted to even look at it. To make matters even funnier, he even cites Carl Sagan (a staunch atheist and brilliant physicist) in an effort to bring some credibility to his claims. Scientists are either quoted out of context or are just flat-out wrong, for science has ultimately proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that this universe, this solar system, this planet, and this species can and do arise independently, without the need for an intelligent creator.

Monday, September 19, 2011

New Book

Well, it turns out that I got the wrong book. I was supposed to be reading New Evidence That Demands a Verdict, one of McDowell's later books. So, I will wait patiently for that book to arrive, do a quick comparison of the first chapter, note any differences (unless everything is vastly different), and proceed with that book.

Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 1: The Uniqueness of the Bible - Part 2

Continued from Part 1.


This post is already getting really long, so I decided to split it up into two sections. Also note that these are all my initial reactions to McDowell's arguments. They are mostly based on my past experience and knowledge gained, but I do some research as well to make sure that my claims have some backing to them. So far I'm not proofreading any of my posts, so I apologize if they are somewhat cumbersome. Anyways, back to Evidence That Demands a Verdict:


McDowell argues that the Bible is the most circulated book in history, ending this section with, "The critic is right: 'This doesn't prove the Bible is the Word of God!' But it does factually show the Bible is unique." Again, I argue that uniqueness does not imply specialness. It only shows that the Christian religion is the most widespread and/or fanatical religion, not that it is true.

Now the argument is that the Bible is the most translated book in history. Now, while that seems like a remarkable feat of accomplishment, doesn't this actually work to its detriment? For it is plain to any original languages scholar that the English Bible that we have today is not the same as the Greek New Testament of the first few centuries. Every time the Bible is translated, errors are made. Mostly small ones, but sometimes big enough errors are made (by mistake or purposefully for political reasons) that greatly influence doctrine and significantly alter the course of religion. (Need I cite again the "hell" issue, which was not on the minds of Jesus or the early church leaders, but due primarily to mistranslations permeates the contemporary Christian culture?)

McDowell claims next that the Bible is unique in that the manuscripts we have today show a very accurate portrayal of the original text, unlike any other writing we have. I will mostly grant this, that save for some copying errors (which have been shown to exist), scribes were pretty careful not to mess up the copies. Still, it is not perfect, and I might expect an all-powerful God to perfectly preserve his word throughout the centuries. Still, I'll grant that the errors in the modern Bible due to scribal errors are generally insignificant. He also lays claim to the fact that the Bible has survived through much persecution over the millennia. True, but, "[t]his does not prove the Bible is the Word of God. But it does prove it stands alone among books. Anyone seeking truth aught to consider a book that has the above unique qualifications." So, what, no other unique religious book has been burned, banned, and outlawed? Certainly, many religions, religious writings, and religious people have been persecuted, leaving only the fittest religions behind. (Oh, the Christians are going to hate me for that analogy!) It's not like all but one religion has coupled under pressure.

The next big section, though difficult to summarize, seems to be saying that the Bible has undergone much criticism and come out standing "as solid as a rock." McDowell quotes a bunch of people saying the same thing, and then cites a couple instances where people have criticized the authorship of the Bible and said, "they have been shown to be wrong." I heartily disagree with this sentiment, for in all the study and research I have done, I have come to believe that the Bible is not so "solid as a rock" as McDowell would like to believe. I'll of course grant that some criticisms of the Bible have shown to be false (though I don't have extensive enough knowledge to comment on the ones McDowell cites), but just because a few people are wrong doesn't mean that everyone who thinks like them is wrong. I can't say much more than this, though, for I need more education in this field of study. McDowell's argument, though valid, is weak and does not actually prove anything.

McDowell quotes a few people saying that because the Bible makes specific prophecies and that these have come true, it must be true. Of course, he fails to cite any of these so-called fulfilled prophecies. If he had, I could go on a diatribe about statistical probability theory, but he fails to mention any of these prophecies that have taken place! However, in my experience, I have not found any kind of a fulfilled prophecy. Most recent is the utterly embarrassing May 21 "Judgement Day" prophecy uttered by Harold Camping. I'm willing to bet that for every "fulfilled" prophecy, we could chalk it up to coincidence and find hundreds, if not thousands, of prophecies that have not come true. But McDowell doesn't give one example. Do I expect too much?

He next claims the Bible to be impressive in its ancient historical account, which no other culture or religion can claim. This would be a valid point if the historical account were completely true, but I have heard that people have done studies and shown that, while the Bible does contain historical accuracies, it also contains historical falsehoods as well. But, I shouldn't fully endorse this point of view without saying that "more research is needed."

The next argument basically says, "The Biblical stories often paint their characters in a negative fashion, and if it were made up, they wouldn't have done this." I do like this argument, and I'll give McDowell a point for this one. I think that this is a very big assumption to make, for you cannot claim to know the motivation of writers dozens of centuries ago. What's to say that they really believed that what they were writing was true? What's to say that they cared that their actions to look as "saintly" as possible? What's to say that it was always a first person account of the stories (as often it was not)? I don't buy this argument, but I can't quite fully refute it either. The motivations of ancient writers are lost in time. We cannot know why they did or did not write things down. It may provide some bit of evidence that what they were writing actually did happen, but there are so many unknown possibilities that I wouldn't put too much weight on it.

After stating to what great extent the Bible has influenced culture around it (sure, he gets another point here), McDowell states, "The conclusion is obvious. The above does not prove the Bible is the Word of God, but to me it proves that it is unique." Well yes, the Bible is unique. If all McDowell wanted to do was come to this conclusion, I'd have to agree with him. But his logic is flawed. He seems to be implicitly making the argument that because the Bible is unique, it alone should be the source of truth. Like I said before, uniqueness does not imply specialness! Every religious book is unique, but that doesn't make any of them true!

So far I have been thoroughly unimpressed by McDowell's arguments, but perhaps they get better.

Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 1: The Uniqueness of the Bible - Part 1

Some people, McDowell not the least among them, think that the Bible is unique and unlike any other book in existence. OK. The Bible was written over a period of many years, by many different people, in many different places, over many different subjects. The Bible is a unique collection of writings. I grant that.

But uniqueness by itself doesn't imply specialness. Consider the Qu'ran, which also makes claim to be unique and unlike any other book ever written:

017.088
YUSUFALI: Say: "If the whole of mankind and Jinns were to gather together to produce the like of this Qur'an, they could not produce the like thereof, even if they backed up each other with help and support.
PICKTHAL: Say: Verily, though mankind and the jinn should assemble to produce the like of this Qur'an, they could not produce the like thereof though they were helpers one of another.
SHAKIR: Say: If men and jinn should combine together to bring the like of this Quran, they could not bring the like of it, though some of them were aiders of others.


In fact, the claim could be made that the fact that the Bible's contents and authors is so diverse is actually detrimental to its validity. For instance, how many times have Christians misinterpreted Scripture because they failed to account for the time period or cultural context it was written in, or the genre of the text itself. Even major doctrinal issues in contemporary Christianity only exist because of failed interpretations of ancient texts! (For instance, many conservative Christians like to read Genesis 1 as a literal account of creation, ignoring the obvious textual problem that this is an allegorical piece of literature! Thus, the relative intelligence of the United States is so far behind that of other countries because so many people insist that the earth can only be a few thousand years old, per a literal interpretation of the Genesis account.)

At any rate, many books are unique. Uniqueness absolutely does not imply accuracy. In fact, it is not even appropriate to count it as evidence for accuracy, because there are plenty of other holy books that are unique to themselves that are obviously contradictory to the Bible.

McDowell also makes the argument that the Bible is in complete agreement (an assertion I would disagree with, but for now I'll grant him this point). He says that, if you were to take just 10 authors of great books in history, "all from one walk of life, one generation, one place, one time, one mood, one continent, one language and just one controversial subject," would the authors agree? McDowell's conversation partner answered, "No!" Thus, the Bible is true.

Proof by contradiction. Suppose I were to take a deck of cards, spread them out before me, and pick out all the spades. I then present this subset of cards before another and say, "Isn't it marvelous that there are only spades in this collection of cards? If you were to pick out even just 10 cards at random from the rest of the deck, would you end up with all the same suit?" "No!" Obviously, the only reason that the cards in my hand are all the same suit is because I purposefully chose for them all to be the same.

It would perhaps be remarkable if the entire Bible was in complete agreement (which I contend it is not) and these Scriptural writings were the only writings ever made pertaining to this particular religion. However, this is not the case. McDowell clearly ignores all the Scriptural Christian writings that didn't make it into the Bible. This is what the Catholic Encyclopedia has to say about the canonocity of the New Testament:
The idea of a complete and clear-cut canon of the New Testament existing from the beginning, that is from Apostolic times, has nofoundation in history. The Canon of the New Testament, like that of the Old, is the result of a development, of a process at once stimulated by disputes with doubters, both within and without the Church, and retarded by certain obscurities and natural hesitations, and which did not reach its final term until the dogmatic definition of the Tridentine Council.
Among the books, letters, and epistles that did not make it into the New Testament were:

  •  Infancy Gospels of James, Thomas, and Matthew
  • Gospels of the Ebionites, Hebrews, and Nazarenes
  • Gospel of Marcion
  • Gospel of Mani
  • Gospel of Appelles
  • Gospel of Bardensanes
  • Gospel of Basilides
  • Gospel of Thomas
  • Gospel of Peter
  • Gospel of Nicodemus
  • Gospel of Bartholomew
  • Questions of Bartholomew
  • Resurrection of Jesus Christ according to Bartholomew
  • Apocryphon of James
  • Book of Thomas the Contender
  • Dialogue of the Saviour
  • Gospel of Judas
  • Gospel of Mary
  • Gospel of Philip
  • Greek Gospel of the Egyptians
  • The Sophia of Jesus Christ
  • Epistle of Barnabas
  • Epistles of Clement
  • Epistle of the Corinthians to Paul
  • Epistle of Ignatius to the Smyrnaeeans
  • Epistle of Ignatius to the Trallians
  • Epistle of Polycarp to the Philippians
  • Epistle to Diognetus
  • Epistle to the Laediceans
  • Epistle to Seneca the Younger
  • Third Epistle to the Corinthians
  • The Shepherd of Hermas
  • Bart Ehrman
  • Book of Nepos
  • 1 and 2 Clement
  • Didache
  • Apocalypse of Peter
  • The Protevangelium of James
and the list goes on... Some of the books of the contemporary New Testament were almost not included in the canon, such as Hebrews and James! There were many multiple conflicting Christian sects and beliefs in the first few centuries, but only one set of teachings prevailed. Thus, it is not remarkable that only a select few of these writings and teachings were canonized and in agreement, while the rest were regarded as heresy.

To be continued.