To start, we have a half hour production from a charity called Invisible Children. If you like, the video is here:
http://www.vimeo.com/37119711
So, the major points of the video (the tl;dr for those who don't care to watch it) are:
- Joseph Kony is the leader of the LRA (Lord's Resistance Army) in Uganda/Africa. He is a very bad man who abducts and enslaves young children, turning them into his own personal violent army.
- Nobody in the Western world knows or cares about this.
- Due to the efforts of IC, Barack Obama authorized a small military contingent to work with the Ugandan government's army to find and bring down Kony.
- Kony has since changed his tactics and moved out of Uganda, and IC is concerned that the US will withdraw its troops at any moment.
- Since it is perceived that we are needed to capture Kony, IC is organizing a massive campaign to raise public awareness of Joseph Kony and to encourage US citizens to demand that their government not remove troops and continue to pursue Kony to bring him to justice.
So there we go. On the surface, this sounds great. Personally, I did not know of Kony or the LRA until the other day when the video went viral on Reddit. However, there are always detractors, and they seem to raise some valid points. Here are a couple sources:
From what I can tell, the major points of the detractors are:
- IC encourages the US to partner with the Ugandan army, which we know is immoral (raping and looting), yet IC makes no mention of this.
- IC spends only 32% of donations to help children, with the rest going toward employee salaries, video production costs, travel, and political lobbying.
- IC has not submitted their financial records to external auditing like a good charity ought to do.
- IC supports direct military intervention, which can (and in this case does) cause violence to escalate.
- IC exaggerates the facts and the magnitude of the evil of Joseph Kony.
I'll tackle these points out of order.
First, point #4, the issue of direct military intervention. Now, I am generally an avid opponent of military intervention. The U.S. does it wrong all the time. Nevertheless, it is important to remember the reason I am against it: because it often doesn't make sense. In this particular case, though, it does make sense! If it is true that the one and only purpose of our intervention in Uganda is to find and capture Joseph Kony, and if it is true that the odds of doing so are much more in our favor with our intervention than without, then it makes perfect sense to intervene!
Furthermore, about the point of escalation. Leaving Kony alone will never make the problem go away. It can only get worse. Intervening may make the problem worse for a time, but (it is hoped) it will be solved quickly. Will some children die in the process? Yes, probably. Is that a sad thing? Yes, certainly. BUT, will more children be abducted and die by the hand of Joseph Kony if we do nothing? Common sense says yes. And, unless someone provides me with hard evidence to support the other view, I must take the position of choosing the lesser of two evils. It is unfortunate that some children will be harmed or killed, but if it means removing Kony from the world for good, it is a justifiable risk.
Second, points #2 and #3, the issue of IC's finances. Frankly, it does not surprise me that "only" 32% of donations go directly towards helping the children, especially when you consider what IC's mission is. Remember, IC's mission is to raise awareness of Kony and remove him from power. That's where all the production costs and lobbying comes in. Alleviating the symptom is great, but curing the root of the disease is more important. I'm glad to see they're doing both, and I don't mind. Now, I don't know what an external audit is supposed to accomplish, but I suppose IC should submit to it. If they are honest, they have no reason to hide anything.
Third, point #1, the issue of partnering with the Ugandan army. So, Kony is bad, and the Ugandan army is bad. I get that. However, is it necessarily unethical for the U.S. army to partner with the Ugandan? If we are implicitly supporting, encouraging, and/or enabling the Ugandan army to do evil deeds, then yes, I would say this is clearly unethical. However, I doubt this is the case and, since the primary effort is to remove Kony, I lean towards giving both armies the benefit of the doubt unless and until hard evidence can be brought up against them. I doubt any army is truly "good", so I don't see the problem of utilizing the Ugandan army to help remove evil from the world.
Third, point #5, the issue of IC's exaggerated claims. This could be a problem. Nobody (except Limbaugh, apparently) denies that Joseph Kony is a very bad man and must be stopped. The issue is whether IC is being completely truthful in what they say. I have not seen precise comments on what exactly the exaggerated claims are - only generalizations. Again, until more specific charges can be brought up against IC, I would tend to give them the benefit of the doubt. And even if they did exaggerate, it depends on how much they exaggerated. If they lied to the point of convicting an innocent man, then yes, this is a huge problem! But is Joseph Kony innocent? Hell no! So does it matter if IC exaggerates some things they say about him? From an ethical standpoint, yes, but from a practical standpoint, it really doesn't make much of a difference.
I didn't really intend this to be a point of support for Invisible Children, but it kind of turned out that way. True, they have some explaining to do, and I hope they do it. But, their behavior (to me) is understandable and their overall mission is sound. I also don't see any major problems in their ethics. So, while I may or may not be comfortable giving them money, I at least fully support their mission to raise awareness of the evil that is Joseph Kony and encourage my government to continue pursuit of said man. Nevertheless, I am always open to new information, new ideas, and new sources. As long as they don't involve Rush. Ahem.


