The other day on /r/debatereligion, someone posted this infographic and asked atheists to defeat it. I have not read anyone else's comments yet, and I thought it would be a fun exercise to make a stab at it. I have no idea if this is the best presentation of the Unmoved Mover argument or if Aquinas himself would agree. I am just responding to it as it appears here.
1. On the second panel, a note is made that Aquinas was not arguing for a beginning to the universe, but rather for a causal power that is operating right now. This is important later. Furthermore, I fundamentally disagree with the quote on this panel from Summa Theologica, but it is completely tangential to the argument and my rebuttal, so I will leave it.
2. "Motion" means "change", which means conversion from "potential" to "actual". Throughout the graphic, the words "potential" and "actual" are used to refer to these kinds of things. The author is equivocating here on the terms "potential"and "actual", as he uses them as adjectives (as he ought) as well as nouns, which is questionable. Still, this problem could be fixed with some clarification, but I understand that he wanted to avoid unnecessary wordage, so I will follow his form.
3. On panel 5, it is stated that "a potential cannot do anything, because it is not an actual. Because potentials cannot do anything, they cannot make themselves actual." This may be true when we are talking about physical objects taking different forms (like water turning into ice or seeds turning into a rose). However, not every "thing" must be a physical object. It is possible to talk about an event as a potential. For example, an event can potentially cease to happen. In this case, the event will realize its own potential once the happening of the event is finished, without the need to be actualized by something else. This is the most important point, which will become apparent later.
4. On panel 7, the argument is made for a chain of dependence (actuals actualizing potentials in a linear fashion) that is happening right now, in the present. I agree with this chain of dependence, but I contest that it must be operating right now. It is physically impossible for a cause and effect to happen simultaneously. A cause must come first, and then, after a period of time, the effect occurs. It can also be the case where a cause can effect, cease to exist, and then afterwards the effect still takes place.
The example used here is of the form: power plant -> freezer -> cold air -> ice. The power plant could cause the freezer to run which can cause the air to become cold. But, because it takes more than a miniscule amount of time for water to freeze, the plant or the freezer could cease to exist (or more simply, stop working), but the ice would still freeze because the air is still cold. Moreover, the air could freeze the ice, cease to be cold, and the ice would still exist (at least for a time). Things take time, so not all causes and effects must happen close together.
5. On panel 9, the assertion is made that this dependence chain cannot be infinitely long, for "an infinite number of inert members cannot do anything". I think this is an unbased assumption and do not find the argument convincing, especially since there is no argument here, only examples. At any rate, I am willing to concede this point for the sake of argument, because it ultimately has no bearing on my counter-argument.
6. On panel 10, the assertion is made that, since the chain cannot be infinitely long, there must be one member at the head of the chain that drives the whole thing. This does naturally follow, except for the part about the "one". If every effect were caused by one and only one cause, then this would be true. But in the real world, effects can (and usually do) have multiple causes. Consider rolling a boulder. One person cannot roll the boulder, nor can two, but three people can. The three people are not chained together (as in, they do not cause or affect each other), but all three people simultaneously pushing on the boulder do affect the boulder's motion. Though the people are not dependent on each other, take any one person out and the effect ceases to happen. This can extend all the way to the beginning of the chain, such that the chain could have multiple uncaused "heads" that all converge to produce a singular effect.
7. On panel 11, the author introduces a definition, and this is where the argument really starts to break down. The definition (which I am perfectly ok with, as long as the word is used consistently) is thus: "Since the chain must have a first member at the head of it, that member must be purely actual." I take it to mean, then, that purely actual is defined as "the head of the chain of dependence", or "something which has no cause" or even more accurately, "an actual that never once was a potential."
On the next panel (12), however, unbased assumptions are made about the attributes of a thing that is purely actual. These attributes are entirely based on the premise that a purely actual thing has no "unrealized potentials." Examples of "unrealized potentials" are not being able to do something, a change in location or form, coming into or going out of being, or lacking knowledge.
In order to make this argument work, great care must be taken in defining what exactly an "unrealized potential" is, and this is perhaps the most confusing part of the whole argument. Taking the language at face value, I would define an "unrealized potential" as a potential thing (some object or form that could exist, but doesn't) that has not (yet) been actualized. Here, I am effectively equating unrealized with unactualized. (If a better definition of unrealized is available, I would love to hear it.)
For an example of an unrealized potential as I am defining it, consider the water again. Here is a labeling of the various actuals and potentials in this situation:
cold air: actual (non-pure, because it was once a potential that has been actualized)
water: potential-ice
water: potential-steam
-> (let time pass)
cold air: actual (as before)
ice: actual (used to be water: potential-ice)
steam: N/A (doesn't exist; unrealized potential)
In this example, the steam is never actualized, so the water has an "unrealized potential". Now back to the definition of pure actual. A pure actual is something that never was a potential. Notice the difference here. Just because an actual was never actualized from a potential does not mean that it does not have any unrealized potentials. It is still possible, in other words, for the head of the chain of dependence to have the possibility of moving or of changing forms after the chain was started (effectively forming two chains).
The point of the matter is this. The Unmoved Mover argument makes the claim that a pure actual, the head of the chain, cannot have unrealized potentials, and so must be existent, omnipotent, non-physical, eternal, omniscient, perfect, immutable, and the only one. Ergo, God. However, nowhere does it follow that something which didn't have a cause cannot have unrealized potentials. Nor does it follow that a pure actual cannot cause an effect and then realize a potential after the fact. When we trace the causality of things back to the very beginning, it is not necessary for the head of the chain to still be around after the first cause; it could have still caused one thing and then realized a potential (such as ceasing to exist) after it did its initial cause.
Consider the Big Bang. If we scientifically trace all cause and effect back far enough, we get to the Big Bang. Like the concept of God, there is no requirement that the Big Bang was caused by anything (or in other words, it is a pure actual, merely by the fact that it never was a potential). The Big Bang, being in nature an "event", can obviously have potentials (such as ceasing to exist), but the fact that it has potentials does not stop it from being the head of the chain. Realizing the potential of not-existing does not require a separate actual in order to actualize it. (See talking point #3 above.)
So to summarize, I find two main flaws with this argument.
1. Dependence chains are not linear; not only can multiple actuals actualize one potential, but one actual can actualize multiple potentials. The chain both converges and diverges.
2. Not all potentials require a separate actual to actualize them. For instance, the Big Bang can exist as a pure actual (uncaused), cause a chain of dependence (the universe), and then cease to exist as an event. It need not be omnipotent, non-physical, eternal, omniscient, perfect, immutable, or the only one to be at the head of the chain.
TL;DR version
The Unmoved Mover argument says that everything that happens is caused by something else. If we trace these cause-and-effects all the way back to the beginning, we end up with "the thing" that is ultimately responsible for everything else. By nature of being the first thing, it is uncaused, and just by nature of being uncaused, it cannot be changed or transformed in any way, so it must be God. I have shown that the first thing could be the Big Bang and then, despite having no cause, cause itself to be something that it is not (namely, a thing that doesn't exist).
ELI5 version
Everything happens for a reason, except for the first thing that ever happened, which we call God. But the first thing that ever happened could have been the Big Bang, which isn't God. This makes a lot more sense, so it's probably true.
Other Responses
There are tons of other ways of approaching this issue, so I will let others' comments speak for themselves. A couple of my favorites are khafra's and tannat's. Now that my brain is fried, time to go back to work!
Home › All posts
Thursday, December 1, 2011
Sunday, October 30, 2011
Bad Sermons and Good Sermons
First of all, administrative: I think I might be pausing my McDowell series while I focus on the more recent Strobel series (I already have the introduction and first chapter done). For one, the Strobel book is WAY shorter, and much easier to refute. It's also more fun. But, I will come back to the McDowell book when that is finished. I just have too many Christian books to read.
And now, for the real content.
Christian, if you haven't realized yet, there are such things as good sermons and bad sermons. If you think all sermons are created equal, I'm sorry to break it to you, but they are most decidedly not. And I'm not talking about whether you like it or not--I'm talking vast differences in quality. Today, for instance, I endured a most painful sermon in a small evangelical church that shall not be named. In this small CMA church, the head pastor took a week off and let a guest pastor take the reins. I was only there to impress my family's friends, but I figured I would give the guy a chance anyways. Before the service began, I punched the verse that was in the bulletin into my Greek New Testament iPod app to get some background so I could better understand the wonderful sermon that was to follow. Oops. (The verse didn't even end up having anything to do with it, so, whatever.)
Oh. My. Science. I was completely unprepared for the horrid deluge of evil, vile shit that would soon spew from this man's mouth. (And, to be clear, I could probably count the number of times I have actually used cuss words on two hands. This should tell you something of the magnitude about how I truly feel about this sermon.) It was absolutely awful. It was so awful that I almost think I would have preferred listening to a hellfire sermon than the garbage he spouted. The basic premise was ok: "Guard your heart so that bad things don't get in and mess you up." Yeah, fine, but the way he delivered it was so god-awful that it made me almost physically sick. I was angry nearly from the start, when he compared the OWS protesters to the evil things that creep into your heart and "occupy" it. I was absolutely FURIOUS when he said that listening to "bad" music or watching "bad" shows turned you into a bad person. I...I don't even want to talk about it. In fact, I know I shouldn't, or I'll be here all day complaining, and it would not be pleasant. Suffice it to say that the brand of Christianity he espoused was not at all biblical, not at all true, and not at all Christian! Everyone else seemed to like it, though, which makes me really scared. I think of those poor children who will grow up in that church and be exposed to sinister, evil lies like that throughout their lives. They don't know any better. They won't know any better. I desperately wish I could save them from that kind of hell. But what can I do?
Then, on the other hand, you have quality sermons! Most of the sermons that come out of Mars Hill Bible Church are pretty good. They are biblically-based, decent words of wisdom, at least as far as Christian wisdom goes. But on the way back from the sickening church service this morning, my wife and I listened to a podcast of a sermon that was given by N.T. Wright on the sacraments a few weeks ago. Talk about night and day! Not only was his sermon fascinating from an educational and theological standpoint, but it was very well thought out, very biblical, and exposed very good theology and a rock solid faith. I hope the guest pastor's sermon never gets saved anywhere in digital form, but if you want to listen to N.T. Wright, I highly recommend it! Here is N.T. Wright on the Sacraments. If you want real quality teaching, take a listen to that.
This whole episode got me thinking more about the Evangelical community and what it means to be a Christian. I think a distinction ought to be made here, and I think it's a distinction that has been a long time in the making. It's offensive, but I've got to say it. Evangelicals, you are no longer Christians. Yes, I know you think you are, but you really aren't. You don't practice what you preach, nor do you even preach the Gospel of Jesus Christ. You have twisted and maligned the words of your Scriptures to such a degree that he would be utterly appalled by what he sees in Christianity today. You are the Evangelical community, but you're not Christian. You have sacrificed the love and grace of Jesus Christ for damning teaching and right-wing conservative agendas to get bigger numbers and to separate yourselves from others and divide yourselves into warring "us vs them" groups. You are divisive, corrosive, selfish, materialistic, and unworthy of the label of the God-man you claim to serve.
Catholics, you really aren't any better. You have sacrificed the humility and earthliness of Jesus Christ for the riches and powers of this world. Do you really think Jesus would be impressed by the fanciful, meaningless rituals and the grand cathedrals you have built? Do you really think he would approve of your idols? No, you too have lost the true meaning of Christianity a long time ago. You also do not deserve the label of the God-man you claim to serve.
True Christianity means something else entirely. Being a Christian means you are a follower of Christ. Evangelicals, I'm mainly calling you out here. You want comfort. You want the easy life. You want to go to church every week and be told that you're such a good person for being "saved," in the in-crowd. You're not going to leave your father and mother and all your possessions to go feed the poor, clothe the naked, and visit the prisoners. You're satisfied with throwing a bunch of money at printing Bibles rather than giving people what they really need. You aren't ready to accept one or a group of people who are different from you in any way or who intrude on your comfortable lifestyle. You don't have what it takes to be a follower of Christ. The moment you do, let me know, and maybe we'll have something to talk about. Hell, I don't believe in God or the deity of Jesus, and I'm more of a Christian than most of you. Try giving your money to starving children instead of "outreach" programs. Try loving your neighbor as yourself, even if your neighbor is black, teen-pregnant, or even gay. At the very least, start trying to spot bad teaching when it hits you square in the face. Not everything that comes from a pulpit is good or wholesome. Or Christian.
And now, for the real content.
Christian, if you haven't realized yet, there are such things as good sermons and bad sermons. If you think all sermons are created equal, I'm sorry to break it to you, but they are most decidedly not. And I'm not talking about whether you like it or not--I'm talking vast differences in quality. Today, for instance, I endured a most painful sermon in a small evangelical church that shall not be named. In this small CMA church, the head pastor took a week off and let a guest pastor take the reins. I was only there to impress my family's friends, but I figured I would give the guy a chance anyways. Before the service began, I punched the verse that was in the bulletin into my Greek New Testament iPod app to get some background so I could better understand the wonderful sermon that was to follow. Oops. (The verse didn't even end up having anything to do with it, so, whatever.)
Oh. My. Science. I was completely unprepared for the horrid deluge of evil, vile shit that would soon spew from this man's mouth. (And, to be clear, I could probably count the number of times I have actually used cuss words on two hands. This should tell you something of the magnitude about how I truly feel about this sermon.) It was absolutely awful. It was so awful that I almost think I would have preferred listening to a hellfire sermon than the garbage he spouted. The basic premise was ok: "Guard your heart so that bad things don't get in and mess you up." Yeah, fine, but the way he delivered it was so god-awful that it made me almost physically sick. I was angry nearly from the start, when he compared the OWS protesters to the evil things that creep into your heart and "occupy" it. I was absolutely FURIOUS when he said that listening to "bad" music or watching "bad" shows turned you into a bad person. I...I don't even want to talk about it. In fact, I know I shouldn't, or I'll be here all day complaining, and it would not be pleasant. Suffice it to say that the brand of Christianity he espoused was not at all biblical, not at all true, and not at all Christian! Everyone else seemed to like it, though, which makes me really scared. I think of those poor children who will grow up in that church and be exposed to sinister, evil lies like that throughout their lives. They don't know any better. They won't know any better. I desperately wish I could save them from that kind of hell. But what can I do?
Then, on the other hand, you have quality sermons! Most of the sermons that come out of Mars Hill Bible Church are pretty good. They are biblically-based, decent words of wisdom, at least as far as Christian wisdom goes. But on the way back from the sickening church service this morning, my wife and I listened to a podcast of a sermon that was given by N.T. Wright on the sacraments a few weeks ago. Talk about night and day! Not only was his sermon fascinating from an educational and theological standpoint, but it was very well thought out, very biblical, and exposed very good theology and a rock solid faith. I hope the guest pastor's sermon never gets saved anywhere in digital form, but if you want to listen to N.T. Wright, I highly recommend it! Here is N.T. Wright on the Sacraments. If you want real quality teaching, take a listen to that.
This whole episode got me thinking more about the Evangelical community and what it means to be a Christian. I think a distinction ought to be made here, and I think it's a distinction that has been a long time in the making. It's offensive, but I've got to say it. Evangelicals, you are no longer Christians. Yes, I know you think you are, but you really aren't. You don't practice what you preach, nor do you even preach the Gospel of Jesus Christ. You have twisted and maligned the words of your Scriptures to such a degree that he would be utterly appalled by what he sees in Christianity today. You are the Evangelical community, but you're not Christian. You have sacrificed the love and grace of Jesus Christ for damning teaching and right-wing conservative agendas to get bigger numbers and to separate yourselves from others and divide yourselves into warring "us vs them" groups. You are divisive, corrosive, selfish, materialistic, and unworthy of the label of the God-man you claim to serve.
Catholics, you really aren't any better. You have sacrificed the humility and earthliness of Jesus Christ for the riches and powers of this world. Do you really think Jesus would be impressed by the fanciful, meaningless rituals and the grand cathedrals you have built? Do you really think he would approve of your idols? No, you too have lost the true meaning of Christianity a long time ago. You also do not deserve the label of the God-man you claim to serve.
True Christianity means something else entirely. Being a Christian means you are a follower of Christ. Evangelicals, I'm mainly calling you out here. You want comfort. You want the easy life. You want to go to church every week and be told that you're such a good person for being "saved," in the in-crowd. You're not going to leave your father and mother and all your possessions to go feed the poor, clothe the naked, and visit the prisoners. You're satisfied with throwing a bunch of money at printing Bibles rather than giving people what they really need. You aren't ready to accept one or a group of people who are different from you in any way or who intrude on your comfortable lifestyle. You don't have what it takes to be a follower of Christ. The moment you do, let me know, and maybe we'll have something to talk about. Hell, I don't believe in God or the deity of Jesus, and I'm more of a Christian than most of you. Try giving your money to starving children instead of "outreach" programs. Try loving your neighbor as yourself, even if your neighbor is black, teen-pregnant, or even gay. At the very least, start trying to spot bad teaching when it hits you square in the face. Not everything that comes from a pulpit is good or wholesome. Or Christian.
Friday, October 21, 2011
Q&A With Bishop Ed Little
The other day, David, my wife and I attended a local meeting of parishioners from Gethsemane Episcopal Church in Marion, IN (for that is where they will both be attending) to meet, greet, and Q&A with the Bishop of the Diocese of Northern Indiana, Rt. Rev. Edward S. Little II. (Fun fact: His father personally knew E.B. White, and his father's name was...Stuart Little.)
Anyways, I expected Bishop Little to be cool, but I didn't expect him to bethat cool! We all asked him some really hard questions, ranging from his life's background and religious experience, to the doctrine and structure of the Episcopal church, to modern issues facing the church including human sexuality and eschatology. I was rather impressed by his reasonableness, friendliness, and biblically accurate doctrinal positions and opinions. In fact, there is really only one doctrinal issue concerning God's salvific plan that I even found room to disagree on, but I do think that his position is very reasonable and mostly (if not completely) biblical. In a couple hours, I have gained a huge amount of respect for this man, for Father Jim from Gethsemane, and for the Episcopal church as a whole. If I were still a Christian, I would love to go there.
The only thing he talked about all night that really gave me pause was his discussion of his conversion and how he knows the truth of God. Essentially, he graduated from Ayn Rand to Christianity (a move, certainly, in the right direction) and from a modern kind of fundamentalist Christianity to a more reasonable, basic Christianity that he expresses now (though I am somewhat extrapolating this latter part). My problem is his basic justification for believing. As far as I could tell from what he explicitly said, it seems like the only reason he believes is because he "feels" God's presence and simply has faith. This is the same answer I keep getting from everywhere, and it is the reason that I simply cannot believe. (Among all the other reasons, but they are somewhat less important in light of this basic epistemological issue.) Faith, as it is trivially easy to prove, is not a valid way of knowing, and I have not met anyone who could prove otherwise. If I were ever to meet with Bishop Little again, I would pose that issue to him to see what he thinks.
But all this to say, Episcopals are cool! I like pretty much everything about them.
Anyways, I expected Bishop Little to be cool, but I didn't expect him to bethat cool! We all asked him some really hard questions, ranging from his life's background and religious experience, to the doctrine and structure of the Episcopal church, to modern issues facing the church including human sexuality and eschatology. I was rather impressed by his reasonableness, friendliness, and biblically accurate doctrinal positions and opinions. In fact, there is really only one doctrinal issue concerning God's salvific plan that I even found room to disagree on, but I do think that his position is very reasonable and mostly (if not completely) biblical. In a couple hours, I have gained a huge amount of respect for this man, for Father Jim from Gethsemane, and for the Episcopal church as a whole. If I were still a Christian, I would love to go there.
The only thing he talked about all night that really gave me pause was his discussion of his conversion and how he knows the truth of God. Essentially, he graduated from Ayn Rand to Christianity (a move, certainly, in the right direction) and from a modern kind of fundamentalist Christianity to a more reasonable, basic Christianity that he expresses now (though I am somewhat extrapolating this latter part). My problem is his basic justification for believing. As far as I could tell from what he explicitly said, it seems like the only reason he believes is because he "feels" God's presence and simply has faith. This is the same answer I keep getting from everywhere, and it is the reason that I simply cannot believe. (Among all the other reasons, but they are somewhat less important in light of this basic epistemological issue.) Faith, as it is trivially easy to prove, is not a valid way of knowing, and I have not met anyone who could prove otherwise. If I were ever to meet with Bishop Little again, I would pose that issue to him to see what he thinks.
But all this to say, Episcopals are cool! I like pretty much everything about them.
Sunday, October 9, 2011
New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 3 - Is the New Testament Historically Reliable? - Part 1
McDowell gives three criteria for establishing the reliability of the NT: the bibliographic test, the internal evidence test, and the external evidence test.
The bibliographic test argues that our extant copies of the NT is reliable because of the method and timeline with which they were passed down:
The bibliographic test argues that our extant copies of the NT is reliable because of the method and timeline with which they were passed down:
- Our earliest extant copies of significant portions are "very close" in time to the date of their writing (250-300 years).
- The number of extant manuscripts of the NT are great in number (counts vary but average around 5600).
- Errors due to scribal errors and deliberate misinterpretations are minor, and no disputed passage influences central Christian doctrine. (Though, I would argue that you would have to define "central Christian doctrine" very narrowly for this to apply; say, the doctrine of the Apostle's Creed, which is a fair standard.)
- There are various versions in different languages.
- There are a plethora of quotes of the NT from early church fathers.
Much of his argument here is summarized in yet another quote (I am finding that over 50% of this book is quotes from other people.): "Since scholars accept as generally trustworthy the writings of the ancient classics even though the earliest MSS were written so long after the original writings and the number of extant MSS is in many instances so small, it is clear that the reliability of the text of the N.T. is likewise assured." Of course, this is true, all other things being equal. I would not be so bold as to say that all other considerations are equal, seeing as how early Christianity was fraught with rivalries and heresies and arguments. It cannot be disputed that the NT was very controversial, and it seems to me that this fact alone would give many people reason to be altered. Nevertheless, I will cede the point to McDowell (or, rather, the people he quotes).
Wednesday, September 28, 2011
New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 2 - How We God the Bible - Part 1
The first part of this chapter deals with specifications about the creation of the Bible, such as what writing materials were used and what the different forms of books were in ancient times. I'll assume that all this information is accurate.
The second part of the chapter deals with how the Bible was formed (i.e., how the canon was developed). It is here that McDowell betrays his own bias. He says,
The books that were selected for the NT canon were decided according to a test of apostolic authority (which seems to contradict his earlier suggestion that books were not selected, but discovered, to have been written by divine inspiration).
In a "response" to my query about the NT Apocrypha, McDowell cites Geisler and Nix (as he seems to do for all of his information thus far) concerning the reasons for the rejection of these books:
The second part of the chapter deals with how the Bible was formed (i.e., how the canon was developed). It is here that McDowell betrays his own bias. He says,
It is important to note that the church did not create the canon; it did not determine which books would be called Scripture, the inspired Word of God. Instead, the church recognized, or discovered, which books had been inspired from their inception. Stated another way, a book is not the Word of God because it is accepted by the people of God. Rather, it was accepted by the people of God because it is the Word of God. That is, God gives the book its divine authority, not the people of God.Of course you will conclude that God is real and the Bible is valid if you start with the assumption that God is real and the Bible is valid! This circular argument only carries weight if you already believe in God and the divine inspiration of Scripture. But a person who honestly questions these assumptions will find no basis for faith in faith itself. McDowell's clearly circular reasoning undermines any points he tries to make, but for the sake of reading what he has to say, I will continue.
The books that were selected for the NT canon were decided according to a test of apostolic authority (which seems to contradict his earlier suggestion that books were not selected, but discovered, to have been written by divine inspiration).
In a "response" to my query about the NT Apocrypha, McDowell cites Geisler and Nix (as he seems to do for all of his information thus far) concerning the reasons for the rejection of these books:
- They were only temporarily or locally recognized.
- They never had more than a semi-canonical status. (Though, what canonical books had more than a semi-canonical status before they were canonized?)
- No major canon or church council included them as inspired books of the NT. (Obviously, no major canon included them, so they were never canonized! This is not only the same argument as #2, but it is a tautology and essentially meaningless.)
- They were only popular because they connected themselves with the canonical books by claiming to have been written by them.
Prima facie, these arguments seem to argue well for the rejection of the NT Apocrypha. However, upon close examination, we see that arguments 2 and 3 are the same and meaningless. (They were never canonized because they were never included in the canon!) This is not a strawman argument on my part unless McDowell (or anyone) can clarify more precisely what they mean by these statements and show how these apocryphal books were somehow different or of a lesser origin as to not make the cut. (And, it should be noted, "divine inspiration" is simply begging the question.) Argument 1 can simply be attributed as a result of their non-canonicity, unless it can be shown that they became substantially less popular before the canon was created (in which case, why was their inclusion debatable?). Even so, it does not prove anything. Anyone can make a list of the 10 most popular books of their time on a specific subject. How does this prove the existence of God? Argument 4 is an explanation for their achieved popularity, but it does not actually differentiate between their kind of popularity and the kind of popularity that the canonized texts enjoyed. How are they different?
All that to say, McDowell answers some questions pertaining to how the Apocrypha was rejected, but not why. What were the thought processes of the people deciding what books to include and which to exclude? When faced with a potential candidate, how did they decide to which category it belonged? If they simply prayed about it and cast lots, then this is again begging the question. If they investigated the authorship of it and discovered that it was written only so the author could "get rich quick," whereas the canonical scriptures were actually written by authentic Christian leaders, then we would have a real metric that would be fairly convincing. But all McDowell presents are four entirely unconvincing "arguments" that require extreme clarification and/or additional research.
McDowell then spends much space focusing on the OT Apocrypha, a summary of those books, and reasons for their rejection. While I don't care so much about these, the reason he gives here are mostly satisfactory. Some arguments are very valid ("They abound in historical and geographical inaccuracies and anachronisms.") and some are stupid ("They teach doctrines that are false and foster practices that are at variance with inspired Scripture." ...this is essentially saying, "They were rejected as Scripture because they weren't Scripture!")
He finally concludes with yet another quote, "No Christian, confident in the providential working of his God and informed about the true nature of canonicity of his Word, should be disturbed about the dependability of the Bible we now possess." Frankly, I am disturbed about the quality of arguments that McDowell uses to defend the Biblical canon.
So far, I am not convinced.
Friday, September 23, 2011
New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Chapter 1 - The Uniqueness of the Bible
I probably won't comment as much on this chapter, because it appears to be basically the same as the first chapter from the previous book, with no new major sections. It still stands that the main point McDowell is making is, "The Bible is unique among religious books, so that makes it worthy of attention." But of course, every religious text is unique, and the Bible shares more in common with them than McDowell is willing to admit. It is simply a non sequitur to claim that uniqueness implies specialness.
He did change one sentence in his conclusion that I would like to draw attention to. Instead of saying, "The above does not prove the Bible is the Word of God, but to me it proves that it is unique," he says, "The evidence presented above does not prove that the Bible is the Word of God. But to me it clearly indicates that it is uniquely superior to any and all other books." While I could admit to his original statement, his revision is superbly elitist and plays directly into my rebuttal. No, unless you first assume that God exists and is like who you think he is like, then you cannot jump from "the Bible is unique" to "the Bible is superior to all other books." This is plain intellectual dishonesty.
So far, I am not impressed.
He did change one sentence in his conclusion that I would like to draw attention to. Instead of saying, "The above does not prove the Bible is the Word of God, but to me it proves that it is unique," he says, "The evidence presented above does not prove that the Bible is the Word of God. But to me it clearly indicates that it is uniquely superior to any and all other books." While I could admit to his original statement, his revision is superbly elitist and plays directly into my rebuttal. No, unless you first assume that God exists and is like who you think he is like, then you cannot jump from "the Bible is unique" to "the Bible is superior to all other books." This is plain intellectual dishonesty.
So far, I am not impressed.
New Evidence That Demands a Verdict - Introduction
As it turns out, McDowell's book The New Evidence That Demands a Verdict is simply an edited and compiled version of his previous two books. This thing is a beast. I'm thinking I should take a slow and steady approach to it, like one chapter a week. In a couple weeks I will be receiving Dawkin's new book, The Magic of Reality: How We Know What's Really True, and I will want to review this book too (as I eventually want to review Keller's The Reason for God and give it a thorough rereading). So much to do, so little time! Compound this with the fact that I am now addicted to Minecraft, and we have a real problem here...
At any rate, I started skimming the introduction to New Evidence, and while I am not giving it a thorough reading, there are a couple of differences I noticed.
McDowell spends a lengthy section discussion the problem with postmodern deconstructionism. While I do agree that contemporary thought is pervaded by a sense of postmodernism, I think that there is a healthy balance of modernism and postmodernism. Too much of one philosophy causes problems. So, without really reading his section, I'll just assume that I agree with him for the most part.
He also examines some logical issues surrounding Eastern mysticism, but since I am about as far from Eastern religions as I can be, I don't feel the need to visit this topic.
McDowell added something, I believe, to his section on Atheism. This is what he says (sorry, quotes): "Sartre found atheism 'cruel,' Camus 'dreadful,' and Nietzsche 'maddening.' Atheists who consistently try to live without God tend to commit suicide or go insane. Those who are inconsistent live on the ethical or aesthetic shadow of Christian truth while they deny the reality that made the shadow." This is absolutely, unequivocally false! Where do I even begin? First of all, to call on Sartre, Camus, and Nietzsche as the representative voices of all atheists is utterly disingenuous. They had massive philosophical and personal issues that do not apply to many, many people. Second, to claim that all atheists who are happy are only happy because of Christianity is completely dishonest to the discussion (if there is one). The point here is to question and critique Christianity, not assume it to be true! Comments like this make me wonder if McDowell is really taking an honest step back or if he is just trying to reassure people who are already Christians who are having doubts, for it does nothing to convince a nonbeliever.
He then discusses agnosticism, and makes several logical fallacies. McDowell seems to be indicating that agnosticism is an alternative to atheism, when in fact they are compatible. I should know, for I am both! A theist is someone who actively believes in a deity; an atheist is someone who actively disbelieves in a deity; an agnostic is someone who believes that absolute certainty about knowledge is unattainable. Most of us are agnostics, and this is something I've come to learn about the world from a very young age. It is not possible to know with absolute certainty that the sun will rise tomorrow, let alone that there is an invisible undetectable supernatural deity. I still believe that the sun will rise, and I have a mountain of evidence pointing to the fact that it will, but I can't claim to know it for sure. Likewise, I am an agnostic atheist. I disbelieve in a deity, but I don't claim to know this with 100% certainty. McDowell counters, "The fundamental flaw in Kant's hard agnostic position is his claim to have knowledge of what he declares to be unknowable. In other words, if it were true that reality cannot be known, no one, including Kant, would know it. Kant's hard agnosticism boils down to the claim: 'I know that reality is unknowable.' " But this isn't true! Now, I don't know what Kant would say, but I claim that, though reality is not ultimately certain, I still have a massive pile of evidence that points me in the direction of the truth. I may not know it 100%, but I do know it 99.9999999%, and that is enough statistical weight to allow me to live my life and claim to know something. There is a huge difference between "having no knowledge of reality" and "not having absolute certainty about reality." (In fact, somewhere in this introduction, McDowell even admits to being an agnostic theist! He says that he cannot prove for sure that God exists, but the evidence points him in that direction, so that is what he believes. As McDowell would say, case closed.)
Then begins the argument from "science." McDowell appeals to the classic argument against evolution by chance, the "obvious" need for an intelligent designer, and some ludicrous false statements about the nature of the universe. The science in this section is so badly done, I am disgusted to even look at it. To make matters even funnier, he even cites Carl Sagan (a staunch atheist and brilliant physicist) in an effort to bring some credibility to his claims. Scientists are either quoted out of context or are just flat-out wrong, for science has ultimately proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that this universe, this solar system, this planet, and this species can and do arise independently, without the need for an intelligent creator.
At any rate, I started skimming the introduction to New Evidence, and while I am not giving it a thorough reading, there are a couple of differences I noticed.
McDowell spends a lengthy section discussion the problem with postmodern deconstructionism. While I do agree that contemporary thought is pervaded by a sense of postmodernism, I think that there is a healthy balance of modernism and postmodernism. Too much of one philosophy causes problems. So, without really reading his section, I'll just assume that I agree with him for the most part.
He also examines some logical issues surrounding Eastern mysticism, but since I am about as far from Eastern religions as I can be, I don't feel the need to visit this topic.
McDowell added something, I believe, to his section on Atheism. This is what he says (sorry, quotes): "Sartre found atheism 'cruel,' Camus 'dreadful,' and Nietzsche 'maddening.' Atheists who consistently try to live without God tend to commit suicide or go insane. Those who are inconsistent live on the ethical or aesthetic shadow of Christian truth while they deny the reality that made the shadow." This is absolutely, unequivocally false! Where do I even begin? First of all, to call on Sartre, Camus, and Nietzsche as the representative voices of all atheists is utterly disingenuous. They had massive philosophical and personal issues that do not apply to many, many people. Second, to claim that all atheists who are happy are only happy because of Christianity is completely dishonest to the discussion (if there is one). The point here is to question and critique Christianity, not assume it to be true! Comments like this make me wonder if McDowell is really taking an honest step back or if he is just trying to reassure people who are already Christians who are having doubts, for it does nothing to convince a nonbeliever.
He then discusses agnosticism, and makes several logical fallacies. McDowell seems to be indicating that agnosticism is an alternative to atheism, when in fact they are compatible. I should know, for I am both! A theist is someone who actively believes in a deity; an atheist is someone who actively disbelieves in a deity; an agnostic is someone who believes that absolute certainty about knowledge is unattainable. Most of us are agnostics, and this is something I've come to learn about the world from a very young age. It is not possible to know with absolute certainty that the sun will rise tomorrow, let alone that there is an invisible undetectable supernatural deity. I still believe that the sun will rise, and I have a mountain of evidence pointing to the fact that it will, but I can't claim to know it for sure. Likewise, I am an agnostic atheist. I disbelieve in a deity, but I don't claim to know this with 100% certainty. McDowell counters, "The fundamental flaw in Kant's hard agnostic position is his claim to have knowledge of what he declares to be unknowable. In other words, if it were true that reality cannot be known, no one, including Kant, would know it. Kant's hard agnosticism boils down to the claim: 'I know that reality is unknowable.' " But this isn't true! Now, I don't know what Kant would say, but I claim that, though reality is not ultimately certain, I still have a massive pile of evidence that points me in the direction of the truth. I may not know it 100%, but I do know it 99.9999999%, and that is enough statistical weight to allow me to live my life and claim to know something. There is a huge difference between "having no knowledge of reality" and "not having absolute certainty about reality." (In fact, somewhere in this introduction, McDowell even admits to being an agnostic theist! He says that he cannot prove for sure that God exists, but the evidence points him in that direction, so that is what he believes. As McDowell would say, case closed.)
Then begins the argument from "science." McDowell appeals to the classic argument against evolution by chance, the "obvious" need for an intelligent designer, and some ludicrous false statements about the nature of the universe. The science in this section is so badly done, I am disgusted to even look at it. To make matters even funnier, he even cites Carl Sagan (a staunch atheist and brilliant physicist) in an effort to bring some credibility to his claims. Scientists are either quoted out of context or are just flat-out wrong, for science has ultimately proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that this universe, this solar system, this planet, and this species can and do arise independently, without the need for an intelligent creator.
